Aces High Bulletin Board

General Forums => Aircraft and Vehicles => Topic started by: 28sweep on March 11, 2002, 07:57:27 AM

Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: 28sweep on March 11, 2002, 07:57:27 AM
Is this aircraft good for anything?
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: MANDOBLE on March 11, 2002, 08:07:43 AM
its guns are good for antitank ops. Personaly, I'm unable to hit a sht with the rockets.
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: keyapaha on March 11, 2002, 08:14:14 AM
i like leveling towns and de acking feilds with it  and is also good on those pesky gv's

 :)
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: popeye on March 11, 2002, 08:18:37 AM
It can take a face full of .50 cal, and keep on going.  Works well on all GV's except the Ostie.
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: mrsid2 on March 11, 2002, 08:24:30 AM
I was shot down by one from D1.2 and he was using rockets. One shot kill.. You must be doing something wrong mandoble :)
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: MANDOBLE on March 11, 2002, 08:43:31 AM
mrsid2, u were shot down?? In a plane? By IL2 rockets??? at 1200 yards???? Yep, I should be doing something definitively wrong cause cant hit a panzer at 500 yards ...
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: HeLLcAt on March 11, 2002, 09:31:17 AM
You guys are all wrong! I use the IL-2 as a fighter, it's a GREAT fighter when the FH's are down. I killed 3 nikis in it and came back to land 5 times. I have 5 kills in it and 0 deaths! The 23mm guns are great to blow up the pilot, just like I did on the niki's. It's climb is actually pretty good for being a "bomber!" It good dive speed, which means you need altitude!

~BlueiceJ~
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: mrsid2 on March 11, 2002, 10:12:44 AM
No mandoble, I was in M-16 and he came to the edge of my range (actually I pinged him quite a lot as he flew low and level)

Next to my surprise I was sent to tower (never saw rockets or smoke trails) and he said he shot me using his custom built rocket sight from D1.2..

Edit: looks like he maybe at 1.0 when launching..



(http://users.kymp.net/cable130/ss.jpg)

(http://users.kymp.net/cable130/ss2.jpg)

(http://users.kymp.net/cable130/ss3.jpg)

Hit dead center, none missed AFAIK.
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: SKurj on March 11, 2002, 10:16:45 AM
Damn thing has a paper tail +(


SKurj
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: Staga on March 11, 2002, 10:42:50 AM
Yep, after reading how hard Il-2 was to shoot down the glass-tail in AH doesn't seem to be right. AFAIR pilots usually tried to shoot the oil-cooler or straight to the cockpit from sides.
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: mrsid2 on March 11, 2002, 11:18:45 AM
It was known that IL-2 had only 1x1 meter vulnerable spot at the wing root + cockpit that could be shot with .50 in order to disable the plane. Very few finnish fighters had cannons though and I haven't seen 109 vs il-2 reports that would give light to the durability against cannons.

Probably they aimed for the vulnerable parts in any case.
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: DarkglamJG52 on March 11, 2002, 11:31:03 AM
Mandoble, the Russian rockets were famous to be effective from very long distances. I have used the IL-2 twice and I destroyed gv's with the rockets, but it was me impossible to explode a tank with the canyons. The biggest problem in the IL-2 of AH it is that very fragile, comparative with the reality.
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: superpug on March 11, 2002, 01:39:34 PM
usually when i use sturmovik its to take revenge on GVs. And it always works:D . As for the fighter part, it could dog fight with very old 109s. But that never went well.:(  But it is a really good deflacker.:D
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: Tony Williams on March 11, 2002, 01:55:02 PM
In RL the Soviet rockets were originally designed for air-to-air use, but turned out to be too inaccurate so were relegated to ground attack.  They weren't accurate enough to hit a tank with any reliability, either, so they generally used them for attacking area targets.

Tony Williams
Author: "Rapid Fire: The development of automatic cannon, heavy machine guns and their ammunition for armies, navies and air forces"
Details on my military gun and ammunition website:
http://www.quarry.nildram.co.uk
Military gun and ammunition discussion forum:
http://forums.delphiforums.com/autogun/messages/
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: salem on March 11, 2002, 02:36:11 PM
It works a treat for building up those bomber perks. Knocked out two Ostwinds with rockets, and a panzer with guns last night; total of about 8.4 points for a 10 minute sortie. Some practice and persistence with those rockets pays off.

Also had a MC205 try to HO me. :rolleyes:

All it needs is the 2 x 37mm cannon option. :eek:

regards,
Salem
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: illo on March 11, 2002, 02:36:51 PM
Yup with .50 you would have to hit il-2 radiator or cockpit.  Any RL pilot account i ever read says that. If you shot il-2 fuselage with .50cal you could hose it all day with no effect.

AH DM is way wrong here.
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: eskimo2 on March 11, 2002, 03:16:17 PM
The IL-2 is the best GV killer in the game IMO.  
The 23 mm guns are the most lethal airborne anti-GV guns out there, even better that 4 x 20 mm Hispanos, again IMO.
The big rockets seem to have a very big punch, close is good enough with them.  They seem equal to about a 250 lbs bomb in GV killing power.  
I regularly get 4 to 8 kill sorties in it.

Tour 25 - eskimo has 15 kills and has been killed 3 times in the Il-2.
Tour 24 - eskimo has 7 kills and has been killed 3 times in the Il-2.
Tour 23 - eskimo has 6 kills and has been killed 1 time in the Il-2.
Tour 22 - eskimo has 9 kills and has been killed 3 times in the Il-2.
Tour 21 - eskimo has 28 kills and has been killed 6 times in the Il-2.
Tour 20 - eskimo has 28 kills and has been killed 18 times in the Il-2.
Tour 19 - eskimo has 63 kills and has been killed 20 times in the Il-2.
Tour 18 - eskimo has 89 kills and has been killed 25 times in the Il-2.
Tour 17 - eskimo has 73 kills and has been killed 31 times in the Il-2.
Tour 16 - eskimo has 73 kills and has been killed 23 times in the Il-2.

My IL-2 advice:
Always take the big rockets.
Don't bother with bombs, the IL-2 climbs too poorly.
50% Fuel is always plenty, the IL-2 climbs poorly.
Avoid flying it when the enemy has air superiority.  The IL-2 can fight, but it's a slow dog.
When engaging enemy aircraft, try to only offer them a HO, its got better armor and great guns.
Against GVs, be sneaky.

eskimo
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: J_A_B on March 11, 2002, 07:58:17 PM
The IL-2's tail wasn't any tougher than any other plane; I'd guess the reason it suffers tail failure is the rest of the plane is a flying tank and the tail is practically the only thing which is even somewhat vulnerable.

J_A_B
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: brady on March 11, 2002, 08:54:36 PM
I agree with eskimo2 compleatly, it is a great tool, and fun as heck.
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: mrsid2 on March 11, 2002, 08:56:44 PM
The whole plane is vulnerable in AH.

I was flying it today just to test it..

It took 4-5 hits from 37mm field ack to lose engine. No other parts lost.

It took 1 ping D800 from m16 to lose wing. Right from the first small 'dingding' the wing fell off.

1 ping from ostwind from d1000 to lose wing.

2-3 hispano hits to lose wing. 4-5 la7 shots to lose wings.

Not very tough is it? Compared to wartime reports which state the plane is vulnerable to .50 fire ONLY in two places, which didn't include the tail.

I had better success killing gv's at a5 when I took b26, droped bombs and shot them with .50's.

They died faster than with IL-2 cannons, b26 took much more punishment too before going down.

Il-2 I scored 1 gv kills / sortie (suicide run (Tm)) where in b26 I killed 2-3 each run.
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: Kweassa on March 11, 2002, 09:12:04 PM
IL-2 is a dedicated LVT killer.
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: J_A_B on March 11, 2002, 10:08:58 PM
If you'd like we can go on sometime in the TA or somewhere and test it out; I'll fly the IL2 and you can lob 20mm shells into me and see how many it takes.  Do this a few times and get an average.   Wouldn't it be better to have some hard evidence to back up your case?    

I'm all for toughening the IL2, maybe people would have a reason to fly it then (although I still think the tail will always be vulnerable in relation to the test of the plane).

J_A_B
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: brady on March 11, 2002, 11:23:06 PM
I have shouldered multiple hits from an osty before, and watched `them take 2 or 3 hits from my osty and keep coming.
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: SKurj on March 12, 2002, 08:13:58 AM
J_A_B  if i get time to up tonight I'll test it with ya +)


SKurj
Title: Il-2 good for anything?
Post by: mrsid2 on March 12, 2002, 08:32:17 AM
It's really weird because my findings about leathality don't seem to coincide with many others.

I'm constantly getting 1 ping deaths (like I mentioned against d800 m-16 in il-2) even in the planes that are supposed to be durable.

I'm used to being shot down if I take just one hit from almost any plane. Part of it can be explained by lag and hearing one ping even as there are many hits.. Yet some of the damages just can'e really be explained. First 1-ping death to m16 (which even sounds highly unlikely) and next sortie an osty 1 pings the wing off, second ping takes the other wing. Different players too so it's highly unlikely it was any kind of cheat.

Of course that has taught survival skills, I try not to get hit at all during the fight - and I get by as my stats show. I don't attack gv's in fighters for reasons mentioned above, nor do I strafe acks. It's a one way run most times..

It's just the inconsistency that makes me wonder sometimes..

For you who don't know this, I'm MrRiplEy in main arena.