Scores to Scratch one Flattop?

[Viper61]

Mr. Bino do you have the scores sir?  Or did I miss them or a comment somewhere below?

[ImADot]

Patience dood...patience.  I myself score on the "fun factor". So according to my calculation, we all won. 

[Bino]

Working on it, sirs! 

[Viper61]

 

No problem Bino 

Hey Dot!!!   

[Bino]

Sorry, folks, but the computer holding my score files is in a house with no electric power since Saturday afternoon, due the freakishly early snowstorm near NYC.

I *will* get the scores posted eventually, but I'm just not sure when that will be.  Sorry.   

[oneway]

I have a data/function reduction of the public SOF (Scratch One Flattop) logs/tables grabbed from the .Org site that has been run through a series of parsing algorithms on a frame by frame basis, converted into a series of objects with values...and a rule/scoring filter consistent with the parameters of 'Scratch One Flattop applied to it to produce a product or result in BBS code as a set of tables...

In English: I got the data...and a result (unofficial of course)...

Out

Oneway

[ELD66]

If you look at logs US had more kills, obj destroyed and less KIA. So I am guessing US won.

[Bino]

Ladies and Gentlemen;

Please accept my humble apologies for the long wait for the October scores.  Although I did lose electric power at home for most of a week, all I can really claim for my excuse is that I have been scrambling up two learning curves: both the public logs and the CM logs.

And I'm almost done!  Really!  I'm almost there, just *this* much left to do!  Please stay tuned...

[Bino]

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
                   FRAME ONE
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

The USN side flew 79 F4F-4 fighters when only 60 were allowed by the rules.
The side was over-strength by 19 planes (32%).  This is judged a rules violation.

-----------------------------------------------------------
USN AIRCRAFT KILLS
D3A1: 45   x 3 pts =  135
B5N2: 18   x 3 pts =   54
A6M2: 26   x 1 pt  =   26
                     -----
                      215
-----------------------------------------------------------
USN SHIP KILLS
CV: 3  x 25 pts =    75
CA: 2  x  5  pts =   10
DD: 8  x  5  pts =   40
                   -----
                    125
-----------------------------------------------------------
USN LANDING BONUS:  28 x 2 pts = 56
-----------------------------------------------------------
USN RAW POINTS TOTAL:  215 + 125 + 56 = 396
USN PENALTY:   -127   (-32%)
-----------------------------------------------------------
USN GRAND TOTAL:  396 - 127 = 269
-----------------------------------------------------------

-----------------------------------------------------------
IJN AIRCRAFT KILLS
F4F-4:    31    x 1 pt  =    31
SBD-5:    11    x 3 pts =    33
TBM-3:    16    x 3 pts =    48
B-25C:     1    x 5 pts =     5
                           ------
                            117
-----------------------------------------------------------
IJN SHIP KILLS
CV - 2   x  25 pts =   50
CA - 2   x   5  pts =  10
DD - 0   x    5 pts =   0
                    -------
                       60
-----------------------------------------------------------
IJN LANDING BONUS: 12 x 2 pts = 24
-----------------------------------------------------------
IJN RAW POINTS TOTAL: 117 + 60 + 24 = 201
USN PENALTY:  +64  (+32%)
-----------------------------------------------------------
IJN GRAND TOTAL:  201 + 64 = 265
-----------------------------------------------------------

========================================
 FRAME ONE RESULT: DRAW
========================================



+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
                  FRAME TWO
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

-----------------------------------------------------------
USN AIRCRAFT KILLS
D3A1:  61    x 3 pts =   183
B5N2:  40    x 3 pts =   120
A6M2:  25    x 1 pt  =    25
                      -------
                         328
-----------------------------------------------------------
USN SHIP KILLS
CV:    3      x 25 pts  =   75
CA:    2      x  5  pts =   10
DD:    5      x  5  pts =   50
                         ------
                           135
-----------------------------------------------------------
USN LANDING BONUS: 60 x 2 pts = 120
-----------------------------------------------------------
USN GRAND TOTAL: 328 + 135 + 120 = 583
-----------------------------------------------------------

The IJN side flew 45 A6M2 fighters when 60 were allowed by the rules.
The side was under-strength by 15 planes (25%).   

-----------------------------------------------------------
IJN AIRCRAFT KILLS
F4F-4:  9       x 1 pt  =    9
SBD-5: 26       x 3 pts =    78
TBM-3:  6       x 3 pts =    18
                           -----
                            105
-----------------------------------------------------------
IJN SHIP KILLS
CV: 2      x  25 pts  =   50
CA: 1      x   5  pts =    5
DD: 3      x   5 pts  =   15
                        ------
                          70
-----------------------------------------------------------
IJN LANDING BONUS: 6 x 2 pts = 12
-----------------------------------------------------------
IJN GRAND TOTAL: 105 + 70 + 12 = 187
-----------------------------------------------------------

==========================================
 FRAME TWO RESULT:  USN STRATEGIC VICTORY
==========================================



+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
                   FRAME THREE
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

The USN side flew 5 (five) B-25C scouts when only 4 (four) were allowed by the rules.
This is judged a rules violation.  Penalty of 15 points.  This is judged a mistake.

-----------------------------------------------------------
USN AIRCRAFT KILLS
D3A1: 57       x 3 pts =  171
B5N2: 19       x 3 pts =   57
A6M2: 44       x 1 pt  =   44
                        -------
                          272
-----------------------------------------------------------
USN SHIP KILLS
CV: 3       x  25 pts =   75
CA: 2       x  5  pts =   10
DD: 6       x  5  pts =   30
                       -------
                         115
-----------------------------------------------------------
USN LANDING BONUS: 56 x 2 pts = 112
-----------------------------------------------------------
USN RAW POINTS TOTAL:  272 + 115 + 122 = 499
USN PENALTY             -15
IJN PENALTY             +90 (18%)
-----------------------------------------------------------
USN GRAND TOTAL: 499 - 15 + 90 = 574
-----------------------------------------------------------


The IJN side flew 71 A6M2 fighters when only 60 were allowed by the rules.
The side was over-strength by 11 planes (18%).  This is judged a rules violation.

-----------------------------------------------------------
IJN AIRCRAFT KILLS
F4F-4: 10       x 1 pt  =  10
SBD-5: 22       x 3 pts =  66
TBM-3:  8       x 3 pts =  24
                         ------
                          100
-----------------------------------------------------------
IJN SHIP KILLS
CV: 2      x   25 pts =  50
CA: 2      x   5  pts =  10
DD: 3      x    5 pts =  15
                       ------
                         75
-----------------------------------------------------------
IJN LANDING BONUS: 13 x 2 pts = 26
-----------------------------------------------------------
IJN RAW POINTS TOTAL: 100 + 75 + 26 = 201
IJN PENALTY:            -36 (18%)
-----------------------------------------------------------
IJN GRAND TOTAL: 201 - 36 = 165

===========================================
 FRAME THREE RESULT: USN STRATEGIC VICTORY
===========================================


+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 OVERALL RESULT:  USN STRATEGIC VICTORY
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++