it couldn't really say. I've only used att. nothing to compair it to.
I would recomend getting your phone through car-toys though. we had a big mix up when we bought ours. the sales girl confused 2 plans when discribing our coverage (we got the shared phones with free calling between them, and she told us the coverage areas was the same as the plan with free nationwide digital roaming, and free longdistance).
so after a couple months the wife took hers with her on a trip back east (we talked everyday thinking the minutes between where free), then she got back and we left for Hawaii for a couple weeks, used the phones to call home and check on the kids, and to talk to each other.
all of this was within the plan as discribed,
we come home to a $300 bill from the KC trip, so I check my account and we owe another $500 for the Hawaii calls.
I call att and ask whats up, as all calls where within the plan. they say the plan I describe doesn't and never did exist. not hteir problem they didn't sell me the plan, take it up with the retailer, in the meantime I owe an extra $800.
I go to car-toys ready to rip someone a new one. all braced for a long argument and threats of lawsuits.
after I explained the problem the first time the guy gets the manager, brings him back and tells him my story(he almost got it word for word), then asks me if theirs anything to add. nothing to add, I just discribed the girl who sold the plan to us and asked what he was going to do about it.
we went to his computer and prined up my statement and car-toys ate all charges over my base fee up to the day I contacted att and found out what plan I was actually under.
no argument and no trying to get out of it. truly great customer service.