ravells: After talking on the 'divorce' thread about the sanctity of marriage and how modern Americans are devaluing it, are you really advocating that financial incentives for marrying somebody of a particular class is a good thing???
I am not advocating any redistributive scheme by a government.
But if I had to choose between subcidising the procreation of dumb and psychotic (both highly-inheritable traits) or intelligent and well-balanced, I know which one I would prefer to have my tax money spent for.
The scheme is crazy because, as far as I know, there is no compelling evidence that the child of two post grads will be any more intelligent than the norm (however that is defined).
There is a multitude of research and mountains of evidence indicating that intelligence is 60-80% inheritable. Two post-grads with measured intelligence of 130 IQ points will have children with an average intelligence of about 122, not 100.
And the children of those children will also have the average intelligence of about 122 because the statistical regression to the mean effect only works for one generation and the subsequent one establishes the new mean.
Considering that it should take about 105 IQ points to successfully graduate from a high school, about 115 IQ points to be able to enter a college and about 120 to go into graduate studies, we would certainly have noticed if children of the post-grads had an average IQ of 100 and half of them were barely able to finish the high school.
lasersailor184: Imperfection is inherent in Human Beings. That's what makes us human. I don't think we'll ever see the cloning of perfect babies.
You do not have to worry about that because the imperfection that is supposedely inherent in human beings is moral, not physical. The genetic manipulation only deals with physical improvements. It strives to bring healthy and intelligent babies but it never claims to do anything about their morality - except for reducing the inheritable trait of psychoticism which makes people more likely to be lazy and immoral.
The cloning will not make perfect babies in any sense unless you have a "perfect" person to behin with - since cloning is just making an exact copy.
miko