There are some planes (190's, 110's) where it's the best chance they have. Only an idiot would try to HO a 110.
For turn fighters, it seems pretty dumb to HO when if you want to KILL them without giving them a chance of them killing you, a HO is the worst choice of moves.
Example: I'm in a Jug and get a 1 v 1 with another Jug. The guy attempts to HO me 9 successive times. I kill him and he salutes me. No salute for the HOtard.
I don't think it's so much the angst about the HO is that it seems on Aces High the last couple of years...it's "The HO is all they know". It takes no skills whatsoever to HO, no ACM, no tactics...just HO. I see 95% of the folks I come up against try it as their move of choice.
Those who say that the HO is a valid tactic ARE correct, it's just that R/L fighter tactics (including Manfred von Richthofen) avoided the HO at all costs after it nearly got him killed. Others weren't so lucky.
Our screen goes red and we end up in the tower ready to fly again.
Others have said it ad nauseum before--the HO is easy to avoid. You can even do a slight maneuver that gets YOU out of the line of fire while you get to HO THEM. We practice it in squad training.
Live by the HO die by the HO. The odds & probabilities on surviving a HO (if that's all you know) are 50-50.
Anyone who complains about being HO'ed because they got killed by it is a putz.
ROX