Survey -- your favorite and least favorite scenarios

[Brooke]

Results for far (for scenarios that have more than 5 votes)

scenario, median rating
Der Grosse Schlag,   5
Ruhr,   5
Coral Sea,   4.5
Battle of Britain 2004,   4
Rangoon 2004,   4
Stalin's Fourth,   4
Tunisia:  Dawn of Battle,   4
Fire Over Malta,   3.5
Battle of Britain 2006,   3
Battle of Britain 2008,   3
Operation Husky,   3
Kurland,   3
Rangoon 2008,   3
Operation Downfall,   2.5

[fudgums]

Heres mine

Rangoon 42 +4 
BoB08 +4
DoB +3.9999998

[Hajo]

Very Good!

[oneway]

Seeing as Dawn of Battle is my one and only scenario and I have no means to comparatively rate it, I won't.

However, stretching back to 1997 and including Air Warrior and through today, It was the most enjoyable online MMP experience to date.

1Way

[Brooke]

Seeing as Dawn of Battle is my one and only scenario and I have no means to comparatively rate it, I won't.

However, stretching back to 1997 and including Air Warrior and through today, It was the most enjoyable online MMP experience to date.

1Way

I am glad to hear that you had fun.

I would suggest that you do rate it.  The rating is meant to be how enjoyable it was to you personally on its own.  As long as you can tell how you felt about it on the scale of +5 = absolutely loved it to -5 = absolutely hated it, with 0 = can take it or leave it, you are good to go.

[Hajo]

I can't remember all of the Scenarios I've participated in but here goes.

DGS +5
DOB +4
BOB (both +4)
Operation Husky +3
Rangoon +3

can't remember the rest......

[oneway]

I am glad to hear that you had fun.

I would suggest that you do rate it.  The rating is meant to be how enjoyable it was to you personally on its own.  As long as you can tell how you felt about it on the scale of +5 = absolutely loved it to -5 = absolutely hated it, with 0 = can take it or leave it, you are good to go.

DoB +5

[gas50]

Tunisia: Dawn of Battle (April, 2009) +4
Battle of Britain 2008 (November, 2008) +4
Rangoon, '42 (2008) (August, 2008) +4
Der Grosse Schlag (October, 2007) +5


All were excellent opportunities to take some time and learn a little history, and to fly with some new people


- gas50

[RTGorkle]

All the scenarios I've participated in have been positive experiences - mainly for the human interaction - meeting and working with new people. I suspect my interest is falling away to due to RL priorities changing over time - but that's affecting my AH attendance in general, not just scenarios.

+3 Tunisia 2009
+4 Der Grosse Schlag
+4 Operation Downfall
+5 Stalin's Fourth
+5 Fire Over Malta
+5 Coral Sea
+5 Rangoon, '42 (2004)

[Twizzty]

I'll add to my previous post:

DoB '08 +2 (GL of 23 Gruppo (C.202's))

I don't know if it was just a fluke, but this one was interesting to say the least. From only 3 members of a squad of 10 showing for more than 1 frame, to RL issues that made me AWOL for frame 2, I just wasn't into this one. (6 kills in frame 4 helped though)

I think next scenario I will just come in as a walk-on, as IMHO it's the way to go. There will be a seat in a uber-ride(scenario wise) that some CO will want to fill. 

 

[Brooke]

6 kills in a C.202 makes you the man!   (I like the C.202, by the way -- I'm not casting dispersions on the C.202 but am impressed with your tally.)

[HighTone]

This is the only one I have done. I very much enjoyed it.

Tunisia: Dawn of Battle = +4

[Twizzty]

6 kills in a C.202 makes you the man!   (I like the C.202, by the way -- I'm not casting dispersions on the C.202 but am impressed with your tally.)

Thanks Brooke, and as always I am equally impressed with your AAR's.


I also want to thank and <S> the CM's and CO's(Kermit and BK) for their time and obvious effort. Without them and everything you guys do we wouldn't be able to have these awesome experiences.

Thanks 

[swareiam]

A little late but... The scenario was enjoyable for me. As the CO of a P-40 squadron. It was hard to keep pilots coming back. Other than myself, all but one pilot by frame 4 was a walk-on. I guess some folks didn't enjoy it or at least didn't enjoy flying the P-40. The P-40 is one of my favoriate planes to fly in the MA. So that was no sweat for me. Once we modified our tactics in the later frames, we were very effective. Good stuff. 

Rating ???

Dawn of Battle Tunisia 1943 (4+)

Looking forward to the next...

 

[Brooke]

[P-40's]. . . we were very effective. Good stuff. 

Rating ???

Dawn of Battle Tunisia 1943 (4+)

Looking forward to the next...

 

Well, let's see. . . .

Frame 1:


Frame 2:

and


Frame 3:


Frame 4:


Alas, any "i flies lat3 warz l33T planez!!!!!!!!" folks who dropped out missed some action.

The P-40 and P-39 are fine planes in 1942-1943 scenarios such as Rangoon and Tunisia.  Especially when coordinated by a guy like Swareiam.