Funny thread in a way. If you take Shuffler's analogy to Nintendo Cheat Codes, that was probably the substance of new guy conversation in the MA for years. "There is no way a K4 can outclimb a mustang"..."that guy probably hacked the code to make his plane lighter"..."he has the warp button on his joystick"..."he has a bot aiming for him"... and so on and so forth.
It would seem though that his other point is valid as well, for the un-educated. Guy builds mustangs as models for years. Saw every program on them. Joins AH and immediately feels like the game is off when he can't demolish a Ki-43 in a turn fight. It is the game, not the plane. That why squads are so important to the game. It was not until I was with the few that I really began to understand what the planes could really do. With the swampdragons, we focused on raids, so I got good with rockets and bombs. The few on the other hand flew fighters more than anything else and did training. It was then I learned about torque, managing throttle, what planes cannot turn right in a dive, etc.
IMHO, if you want the game to survive, you have to 1. not be a dick and 2. not be selfish. There will always be turds in the game who enjoy picking guys off the runway, but for most it is just a phase. The game became much more fun to play what someone taught me, over time, how to fight. Heck, I used to roll a P-38 with the 80th, just to get tips on crashing on the runway without exploding, to land some 38 kills <S> fellahs.
No restriction will help. The perk rides, really are not that big of an advantage unless they are in the hands of a few of the players who have reverted to score-wh mode.
Personally I just got back from the middle east, again, and am going to get some family time in before getting back into the game. I left the game because my last two jobs would have AH competing for my fractional family time (MAJ KD for vets).
In the end, it is and remains the people that would draw me back to the game. For 10-years or so, I made some good on-line firends. Had a chance to meet a couple in person. The community is what would pull me back, more so than the game. Really, how many WWII airplane nerds are out there? Can your kids/wife distinguish the lines of a P-51 vs. P38? Lol.
Don't be a dick, welcome new people in, invest time getting to know the new folks. If it had not been for SLAYEM, H, and the other swampy's I don't know how long I would have stayed in the game.