I have been listening to Floyd since I can remember.......I'd have to say Dark Side is still my favorite, although I would give Reason a close second. I always find it funny when people say 'waters was pink floyd!!!', um, no actually the band helped write the music, especially Gilmore, who wrote some of the best tracks on The Wall.....Comfortably Numb, Run Like Hell, One of my Turns, Hey you......remember who wrote those guitar licks the whole album....
To me, Waters just let stardom get to his head a bit too much, it's too bad they don't have him no more, but I really don't think he was the whole band.....to me, a band is a 'group', hence 'more than one'........Where would Waters be if there was no Pink Floyd?
I also did get to see them on the Division tour, still the best light show I've ever seen in my life; don't think anyone has even come close.