Originally posted by demaw1
Subaros....
The first thing I did was answer your question, please read it again slowly.
Now, I never said round up or the other, you may infer what you will, and if you will own up to the fact, I never said those words ,then I will explain the other way to interpet the thread.
I read just fine, thank you. How about you try your shot at reading again?
Actually you didn't answer my question. You just asked more questions and added comments out of context (grenade example and shooting in the back example).
I'll spell it out for you:
You asked this question in your title:
Should America deny military service to Muslims?
I answered with:
No.
Where were you with your "rounding up" questions when it was the white guys selling out secrets to the Soviets and Israelis? Using your logic, shouldn't we ban white people from serving in the military?
What's the next question, rounding up all Muslims to internment camps?
I'm with MT as well as others on this...dangerous idea.
Don't punish the whole for what a tiny minority fraction of a "group" does.
My question asking you if you were going to ask "What's the next question, rounding up all Muslims to internment camps?" was legit as this would be the next logical step using your train of thought.
I'll explain it further for you. If we go by your lead and way of thinking.
1st step: You eliminate all Muslims from the military as they are a threat to our military.
2nd step: We next have to round up all Muslims in other sectors of society as well as they are a threat.
Like it or not, that's how I see you going with this. that's why I asked you. Instead of saying: "Of coarse not!" We run around in a semantics battle and of who said what.
