Seems your confusing what the actual benefits of the perk system is, thinking it's only to give high point player better aircraft. That's not what its all about.
I don't think they are as much about "rewarding" someone, as they are to try and balance out the MA by giving people incentive to fly say a LA5, rather than a Chog every mission. Thats a good thing.
Also, it will supposably allow introduction of diffrent late war fighters, in a non-balance destroying fashion. That in fact "rewards" everyone by allowing more cool features.
Will that be worth having to put up with people crying and pissing, and moaning?
I suppose, cuz if its not cannon, FM, padlock, not enough of one country planeset, gangbanging, killstealing, cheating, muteing, hardware requirments, etc... it will be the next game change, in this case a new perk system, that is whined about. (remember the Osti? holy....!)
If it makes you feel better, I think some of the higher scoring pilots are going to cash in on their perk, only drive themselves nuts running around at 35K in their Dora staying outta any possible perk losing dogfights.