Sounds like you did well. Like most said, having anything small enough to keep in your pocket is the reason to get these types of cameras, and the quality for $200-300 is amazing. I've taken tons more pictures of stuff I would have missed just because you could drop it in your pocket.
You could have been extra cool and dropped $200 more for a really wacky 7 megapixels camera, but even at 4, hell, even 3, you will be reducing them bigtime in photoshop or fireworks anyway unless you plan to print 8X10 glossys of your trout for the ladies.
One thing you will dig in the features department is the night modes, and manual modes. You can do quite a bit, although maybe your coolpix did all that. My first and only did not, and the pictures usually stunk unless it was optimal conditions, and good lighting outside. Now i can get a good shot in almost any conditions.
edit- I currently have the Nikon CoolPix 995 and I'm getting rid of it simply because it's too big. It's got a bunch of manual controls and takes nice pictures and stuff, but it's just a pain in the bellybutton to lug around with you at a party/family gathering. Plus, I don't care enough to use most of the manual controls.
Sorry, duh. Looks like you got it. The selectable auto modes for most conditions will work really well. Choosing "Autolevels" in Fireworks makes what it didn't do well, pretty much as good as you need.