I like the answer that states a HO is when both pilots having a firing solution.....
That brings us to good HO's, and bad HO's. I maintain starting on your six, leading your Immelmann and killing you at the top, even if somewhat front on, is a legitimate ACM and kill, not to be confused with the bad HO.
I honestly don't care if someone tries to HO me, but I am sticking with the bad HO being the long merge, face to face, and firing rather than ACM.
Anyway, by the first definition, he had no firing solution on me, so no HO.
It was not Shane....it was another whiner of some infamy.