Flashpoint Taiwan Straits
A look at one of the most dangerous places in the world
Articles from the Journal of Electronic Defense and Edefenseonline
by Kenneth B. Sherman
Mar. 16, 2005
In May 2004, a flotilla of Chinese warships sailed slowly down the length of Hong Kong's Victoria Harbor in an effective show of force. Officially, the People's Liberation Army described the visit as "an event to honor the PLA Navy's 55th anniversary." Clearly, the subtext was that the People's Republic of China (PRC) was striding confidently on the world stage. This display – the first since the colony's return to China in 1997 – came as pro-democracy advocates were grumbling about Beijing's clamp-down on any appearance of self-determination for the former British colony. Two guided-missile destroyers (Shenzhen and Harbin, Sovremmenyy-class guided-missile destroyers purchased from Russia), four guided-missile frigates, and two submarines with their crews standing topside in dress whites demonstrated China's military strength.
The guided-missile cruiser USS Chancellorsville (CG 62) leads the People's Liberation Army Navy guided-missile destroyer Shenzhen (DDG-167) into Apra Harbor, Guam, during a port call in October 2003. The Shenzhen and the oiler Qinghai Hu (AO-885) made the People's Republic of China's (PRC) first ever naval port call to the island. By all accounts, the PRC is working on developing a true blue-water navy.
While Hong Kong was the venue where Beijing showed the flag, clearly it hoped other eyes were watching as well. Previous demonstrations have been more forward. In the fall of 2003, Beijing sailed a Type 035 Ming-class submarine through the Osumi Strait, about 25 miles off Japan's coast. Startled, Japan didn't know about the presence of this sub until it surfaced. Japan then responded by trailing it with one of its P-3C aircraft. Embarrassingly, the Type 035 is a remodeled Romeo-class submarine, an antique design based upon the German Type-21 U-boat of 1944. Just to make sure no one missed the point, the diesel-electric sub flew the PRC's red flag. The sub then submerged and went on its way, leaving an agitated Japanese public to wonder what the hell had just happened and what it meant.
The submarine reportedly belonged to the East Sea Fleet of the PLA Navy and may have sailed from Zhoushan, in Zhejiang Province. This fleet's major mission is reportedly focused exclusively on Taiwan. It is also capable of blockading the East China Sea and hence stopping US aid from the sea.
Such points are not lost on Taiwan. In August 2004, Taiwan Prime Minister Yu Shyi-kun stated that the PRC is busy mapping underwater topography in the Pacific in preparation for an eventual conflict with the United States there. Chinese surveillance ships have passed close by Japan over 20 times since 2003, frequently tweaking Taiwan by passing just east of the island. Such underwater mapping could be, of course, a prelude to conducting submarine operations in the area. According to press reports, Yu said Beijing's aim was to break the US defense line in the western Pacific – a line that runs through Taiwan, Japan, and the Philippines. Another report quoted him as saying: "Communist Chinese forces are coming to the Pacific Ocean for a confrontation with the United States. This causes a threat to security in the Asia Pacific."
Building Up
The People's Liberation Army (PLA) is huge. The PLA Ground Force has 1.9 million men, 14,000 tanks, 14,500 artillery pieces, and 450 helicopters. The PLA Air Force has 470,000 airmen, 2,550 jet fighters, and 400 ground-attack jets. The PLA Navy has 250,000 sailors, more than 70 submarines of all ages and conditions, including the Han nuclear attack and Xia ballistic missile boats; 20 destroyers; 35 frigates; and numerous other craft. There are also the Second Artillery Force (Strategic Missile Force) and the Peoples Armed Police.
Writer Jeff Head, author of the "Dragon's Fury" series of novels about a coming war between China and the US (
http://www.dragonsfuryseries.com) said that the Chinese are currently embarked on a major shipbuilding program for their navy, a massive buildup where they are currently deploying seven new major ship classes at one time, building up to two of these new ships in each class per year. These include two more Project 956 Sovremennyy-class guided-missile destroyers (DDGs), the Type 52B DDG, the Type 52C Aegis-like DDG, the Type 54 guided-missile frigate, the brand new Yuan-class diesel attack sub (to augment the advanced Kilo-class (Project 636) they purchased from the Russians), the Project 093 nuclear attack sub, and the Type 094 nuclear missile sub.
The Project 965 Sovremennyy guided-missile destroyers are equipped with the improved P-270 (3M80) Moskit (NATO: Sunburn) anti-ship missile with a range of 140 miles (see "Cruiser and Destroyer Killers"). This missile is also likely to be installed aboard Luhu- and Luhai-class destroyers and Jiangwei-class frigates. Russia is also said to be selling China eight Kilo-class diesel-electric submarines equipped with the Klub-S submarine-launched anti-ship missile. And in May, 2003, the PRC launched its first destroyer equipped with a domestically built advanced ship missile system (ASMS) for area air defense. The Aegis-like system has been dubbed "the magic shield of China." The PLAN thus joins the US, Russian, Japanese, and (South) Korean navies as the only ones in the region that possess such technology. Such an ASMS permits a fleet or task force to defend itself from multiple missile attacks launched from any direction. The Magic Shield ship reportedly embodies a semi-stealth shape with radar-absorbing and -deflecting materials above the main deck. It is said to carry a Chinese-made, four-faceted, phased-array radar similar to the Aegis' SPY-1D(V) three-coordinate phased-array radar. The Magic Shield destroyer carries far less sophisticated weapons, including a single 100mm main gun and a vertical-launch missile system carrying both anti-ship and air-defense missiles that are reported to be less sophisticated than those carried by its Aegis counterparts.
In May 2004, several photographs appeared in the West of an apparently new class of Chinese submarine being built at the Wuhan shipyard, 420 miles west of Shanghai. It appears to be slightly larger than the Soviet-designed Kilo class, officially named Project 636. The US Department of Defense (DoD) has dubbed this new sub the Yuan class (class 04X). Its design appears to have drawn some features from both the 039A Song class and the Kilo. The Chinese press claims that the Yuan is an improved version of the Kilo, modified with an air-independent propulsion (AIP) system, the current nightmare for the anti-submarine warfare community as it allows a diesel sub to remain submerged for days without snorkeling and thus be essentially undetectable using passive sonar when running on batteries. While Washington initially discounted the Chinese claims, further analysis of pictures has caused something of a stir in Western naval circles. Aside from AIP, the Yuan appears to have a larger hull, diving planes on the sail vs. the hull (as most US subs long have had), and other differences. The Yuan is also believed to be capable of launching YJ-8 series anti-ship cruise missiles as well as carrying 533mm wire-guided torpedoes. One source suggests that the Yuan incorporates a double-hull design integrated with advanced noise reduction techniques, including anechoic tiles, passive/active noise reduction, and an asymmetrical seven-bladed skewed propeller of the type long favored by the West but difficult to produce.
China received its first 30 Su-30MKKs in 2000. Subsequently, the PRC has acquired more while arming them with a variety of weapons, including the Kh-29T air-to-surface missiles, and the KAB-500Kr glide-bomb. It also carries the Gsh-301 cannon and several types of air-to-air missiles. In 2002 China upgraded its Su-30s with the C-801 anti-ship cruise missile.
PLA Air Force
The PRC is in fact in the midst of a major submarine-building effort, and will soon have more classes of subs than any other country. China is believed to think of its subs as its first line of naval power, as the aircraft carrier is for the US Navy. Unable to compete in aircraft carriers with the US any time in the foreseeable future, China seems to be creating a sub force that has offensive as well as defensive capabilities. With approximately 57 submarines now, China may soon have over 100 fully operational boats, despite the huge cost of the effort. Recently, the PLA Navy appointed a submarine-trained admiral as its top officer, another event signaling the importance of submarines to its plans.
In comparison, the armed forces of Taiwan number approximately 430,000 for all services, plus 3.8 million reservists of varying degrees of usefulness; conscription remains universal for men. Taiwan is decreasing the size of its military with a targeted end strength of 270,000 by 2012. Taiwan traditionally has had far more sophisticated military equipment than China, thanks to continued support from the US. Head notes that this is changing as China comes online with such aircraft as the Su-27 and Su-30, as well as so many new ship classes. When you consider the new Type 52B and Type 52C vessels, along with the Sovremennyys, Kilos, Type 093 and Yuan subs, the ROC must get AEGIS destroyers quickly or they will be in danger of falling behind since China is now developing its own Aegis-type system (see below). While Taiwan has benefited from such aging weapons systems as early-model F-16 fighters and Perry-class guided-missile frigates, rearming Taiwan is one of the Pacific's continuing hot buttons.