As weapons platforms the f-15 and f-14 both can 'reach out, reach out and kill someone'.. the BVR capabilities are top notch.
In a knife fight, the advantage goes to the guy that can turn better, climb/accel faster, employ his guns most effectively.
This kind of fighting is all but non existant in a 'Fleet Defense Role', the name of the game is 'reach out and touch'.
It's a moment Tomcat pilots dream of.. and they unquestionably have the superior mount for for the knife fight. As always, the Navy's planes were desigined for the previous war. Imagine what Duke Cunningham coulda done that day with a Tomcat instead of a gunless F4.