Author Topic: Corporal punishment - a discussion  (Read 465 times)

Offline mora

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2351
Corporal punishment - a discussion
« Reply #15 on: December 16, 2005, 05:06:58 PM »
Quote
Originally posted by Tarmac
He got out, took some computer classes, got his GED, and started an ISP (since nobody would hire a convicted felon), and has since moved on in the IT world.

Why release them back to the society at all if they are tagged as criminals? It's good way to ensure that they will commit crimes again, just out of desperation. I've nothing against stiff sentences, but ones you've paid your debt to society you should get another change. Those who can't be given another change because of public safety shouldn't be released at all.

Offline mora

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2351
Corporal punishment - a discussion
« Reply #16 on: December 16, 2005, 05:22:44 PM »
Quote
Originally posted by Tarmac
The difference is that corporal punishment would be subject to rule of law and due process.

I do realize that, but in my view there's no defference. There's a reason why there's no due process for corporal punishment of criminals. And I don't think there should be due process to corporally punish school children either.

I'm not totally against using corporal punishment when bringin up children. It should be up to the parent, but should be applied to very young children only. I'm totally against using it in a public institution, especially in a one which is mandatory for everyone. In a private pre-school with parental consent, I've no problem.

Offline Tarmac

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3988
Corporal punishment - a discussion
« Reply #17 on: December 16, 2005, 05:34:15 PM »
Quote
Originally posted by mora
Why release them back to the society at all if they are tagged as criminals? It's good way to ensure that they will commit crimes again, just out of desperation. I've nothing against stiff sentences, but ones you've paid your debt to society you should get another change. Those who can't be given another change because of public safety shouldn't be released at all.


I provided that example to show that it is impossible at the time of the trial to determine if a person will reform themselves on their own or not.  There are lots of people that commit their first armed robbery and never get out of the cycle of crime.  My cousin did escape, and is doing well now.  Of course, if someone was and will be a serious threat to public safety, imprisonment will accomplish something that beating/caning/whatever will not - incapacitation by removing them from society.  

Quote
Originally posted by mora

I do realize that, but in my view there's no defference. There's a reason why there's no due process for corporal punishment of criminals. And I don't think there should be due process to corporally punish school children either.


You see no difference between:
--a few cops acting illegally and beating a suspect who has not stood trial and
--a court in Singapore sentencing a man to be caned for a crime he has been proven guilty of?

Am I understanding correctly?

Offline lada

  • Silver Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1810
Corporal punishment - a discussion
« Reply #18 on: December 16, 2005, 05:39:18 PM »
Quote
Originally posted by Skuzzy
Those that became criminals probably slid past the paddlings Silat.  :D

We use to have 'licks' championships every year where I went to school.  I was 8th grade champion, and runner-up for 9th grade and see how I turned out?
:rofl


booo .. i have no balls to ask what did you lick at that time :D
(specialy after so many "teach abused young boy" :D )

Offline indy007

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3294
Corporal punishment - a discussion
« Reply #19 on: December 16, 2005, 05:45:00 PM »
Quote
Originally posted by Rolex
Let's throw a little shame and embarrassment into the mix and see what happens.


Well... it worked for the Cultural Revolution.. I geuss...


Offline DREDIOCK

  • Plutonium Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 17775
Corporal punishment - a discussion
« Reply #20 on: December 16, 2005, 08:03:09 PM »
Quote
Originally posted by Yeager
When I was in Jr High, the Principle had a baseball bat that had been plained flat like a board and had 1/2" holes drilled across the flat surface to allow air to pass through (to reduce air resistance and to increase velocity on its unstoppable arc towards the soft tissue on the buttocks).  It was a genuine two fisted mass complicator of youthful bliss.....

I was smart enough to evade its crippling blow but several friends were reformed by its devastating impact.   I think we had only one guy in the entire school that went on to a life of crime and punishment.  Most learned about consequences by way of that principle, and his plained basball bat.

By the time I got into High School the state had outlawed corporal punishment.  Im sure we as a society are not better off in the absence of corporal punishment.



AHAA! SEE THAT!

You had 1 guy out of hundreds that went on to a life of crime.
Thats proof positive that corperal punishment does not work!

Cause lord knows if it doesnt save just 1 person.....

Wait I think I got that wrong;)
Death is no easy answer
For those who wish to know
Ask those who have been before you
What fate the future holds
It ain't pretty

Offline moot

  • Plutonium Member
  • *******
  • Posts: 16333
      • http://www.dasmuppets.com
Corporal punishment - a discussion
« Reply #21 on: December 16, 2005, 10:10:27 PM »
Corporal punishment does what concise and precise reasoning can't.
Either the punisher or the punishee is stupid, or both.
Someone who knows Good will do nothing else.
« Last Edit: December 16, 2005, 10:12:39 PM by moot »
Hello ant
running very fast
I squish you

Offline Shamus

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3583
Corporal punishment - a discussion
« Reply #22 on: December 16, 2005, 11:08:48 PM »
Quote
Originally posted by Tarmac
The difference is that corporal punishment would be subject to rule of law and due process.  


Well if you can put rules into effect to control it, it may work.

When little shamus was 10 he threw a spitwad at a kid and the old guy teaching the class lost it and proceeded to tear poor shamus's shirt compleatly off, blacken one eye and fatten his lip. The teacher from the class next door heard the ruckus and came in and pulled him off.

Now my floks being from the old school figured that even though the punishment was a bit excessive, they wouldnt push the issue, but I guess the other teacher did, as the old guy never returned, this is one extreme.

In JR. and Sr. high the coach and phys ed teachers were always wailing those of us who were smart azzez on the butt with the frigging big wood paddle with the holes in it, it produced a welt, but it was no big deal. You did think a bit more before you shot off your mouth the next time. this is the other extreme.

So I guess I dont like the concept of corporal punishment for the young kids.

shamus
one of the cats

FSO Jagdgeschwader 11

Offline Suave

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2950
Corporal punishment - a discussion
« Reply #23 on: December 16, 2005, 11:21:19 PM »
Coporal punishmen teaches children an invaluable life lesson. He who hits hardest makes the rules.

Offline mora

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2351
Corporal punishment - a discussion
« Reply #24 on: December 17, 2005, 08:27:04 AM »
Quote
Originally posted by Tarmac
You see no difference between:
--a few cops acting illegally and beating a suspect who has not stood trial and
--a court in Singapore sentencing a man to be caned for a crime he has been proven guilty of?

Am I understanding correctly?

Yes I see  the difference, but the western justice system doesn't issue corporal punishments. I dont't see how it can be legal or morally acceptable to beat school kids, if it's even illegal to beat criminals. I also wouldn't trust teacher to issue corporal punishments, it's pretty near of a situation where cops are beating a suspect. Even in singapore they are handed by court and the suspect has a chance to defend himself.

Offline wrag

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3499
Corporal punishment - a discussion
« Reply #25 on: December 17, 2005, 11:50:38 AM »
I find myself looking upon this subject with mixed thoughts.

I'm fairly sure I'm not alone.

Of all forms of discipline, self-discipline is the best.  The best form of control is self-control.  In fact IMHO the Bill of Rights and the Constitution don't work to well without them.  And IMHO both are heavily based on them.

I was once told by my GrandFather that if I was unable to develope self-discipline to beware as there was plenty of people in the world waiting to apply their form of discipline upon me.  If I could not control myself .... same thing.  He pointed out the NAZI's and the things they did, and threw in Joseph Stalin, etc.

Children, and sadly some young people, need to develope self-discipline and self-control.

The manner used to teach them is the issue involved I think.

Violence is all around us.  Happening every second of every day.  It is Nature.  And Nature is very unforgiving.  

True we are thinking beings.  This supposedly puts us above Nature?

I find myself thinking WTF is with this attitude/ thought process that equates advanced civilization with non-violence?  It seems un-natural, anti-nature, even possible anti-progressive?

When I was young, shut-up Silat LOL:lol, you could say whatever pleased you IF you could take the results.  Say some things and say them about them  about certain people and you would find yourself dealing with the results, possibly at the local Dr. office, or the hospital emergency room.  The police and the courts did sometimes get involved but there was a mmm "code" involved.  No person had to except certain things.  A reasonable person kinda thing.

The base for this code was often would YOU care to have such things said about YOU or loved one.  That and reputation.  People tended to judge you, ya there it is the word "judge", by your reputation.  If it was KNOWN you lied  ALLOT .... well you can get the picture.

Now it's to the courts and pay the lawyers etc.

Used to be cheaper, most of the time, to deal with it the other way.

OOPS kinda got off topic here sorry...........

Anyways.........

Some believed pain to be the fastest teacher.  And for some people, with a certain type mindset, the best, and possibly only, teacher.

The concept is THINK!  Before you do or say anything THINK!  That is the totallity of the concept.

How to get some people to think is the problem.  Far too many don't think it through before they speak, type, or do something.

Consideration, walk a mile in the shoes, whatever.  Too many seem to avoid such.

DANG off topic again.

IMHO there are people that exist in the world that place the rest of us in danger every second of every day.  (YA YA I know, some call those people politicians :lol)

What do you do with these people?  How do you deal with these people?

IMHO Some, unfortunatly, should/must be removed for the saftey of our families.  ( the news media report stories that prove this far too often )

SO IMHO an advanced civilization does NOT equate with non-violence.  We haven't come far enough as a species to create such a society.  We still have salvery, we still have people lusting for power and control seeking leadership of countries, we still have individuals willing to do murder to acheive their goals.  IMHO NO amount of media fluff can change that reality.
It's been said we have three brains, one cobbled on top of the next. The stem is first, the reptilian brain; then the mammalian cerebellum; finally the over developed cerebral cortex.  They don't work together in awfully good harmony - hence ax murders, mobs, and socialism.

Offline Tarmac

  • Gold Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3988
Corporal punishment - a discussion
« Reply #26 on: December 17, 2005, 11:53:06 AM »
That's my whole point -- why isn't corporal punishment used by the courts in western societies?  I'm thinking along those lines -- schools are another issue altogether, as (of course) it's going to be harder to ensure that they follow due process and such, not to mention you're also dealing with juveniles.