Conversation from the main country channel last night:
Part of the complaints of the Spit XVI may have nothing to do with its real life performance, but of its ACES HIGH capability. A lot of guys I was talking to think that some of the 16's performance may be punked.
I've seen 16s do some seriously fubar things. I've been in 450-500mph dives, when a Spit 16 latched onto my tail, FROM LEVEL FLIGHT, and immediately began closing distance on me. Top level speed in a 16 is what, ~360-380mph at the atlitudes most fights take place in the MA? And yet these guys are closing distance entering a diving tailchase from level flight within only 2-3000ft, against a target that ALREADY had a serious head of steam (and when I need to jet, I go down full power/WEP)? Other guys in the MA have seen the exact same thing happen against aircraft that are supposed to be among the best divers (P-47s, F4Us, Doras, etc), so I KNOW it's not me (well, diving may not be a good example as it's been frequently reported the whole dive model is porked, but there were other examples of 16s doing things that they really shouldn't).
So there MAY be something to the complaints over the 16, but the best approach would be to fix the flightmodel, THEN see if it should still be perked.