Originally posted by eagl
D50
nikon 17-80 lense (kit lense from D70)
nikon 55-200 lense (only adds $170 to combo cost)
With a camera bag and a few other goodies, it comes out to almost exactly $1000, far less than the cost of the D200 body alone and right around the cost of just the d70 and 17-80mm lense.
You should consider D50 + the new
Nikkor AF-S DX VR 18-200mm F3.5-5.6G IF-ED, which runs for about $700.
Only problems I really see with the lens:
11.1x zoom range - results in more distortion than with normal zooms, albeit possible to fix for most parts with photoshop etc.
Slow lens - F3.5-5.6 will require more light / longer exposure time, although your kit choices aren't much faster. However, the VR II system can result in two steps lower F, comparable to F1.5-3.6, but only for photos of static objects. Useless with moving objects.
I've been considering to buy it when I'll have money for it.
Although I've been also considering an alternative...
Tamron 28-75mm F2.8 ($400) and
Sigma 135-400mm F4-5.6 ($500), a bit more costly combo than the 18-200mm alone.
I hear the Tamron lens is quite good, albeit lacks quality control (might need to be returned for a better copy), but it's a fast lens which is really helpful in low light. Lacks a vibration reducing system though, but that only helps with static objects anyway.
The 135-400mm lens isn't quite so fantastic, although it would give me the range between 200-300mm that I would lack with the Nikkor lens.
Of course I could wait for over the summer (or could I? Mr. Impatient) and get along with my kit lens, Nikkor 70-300mm, and then invest into either of the two choices:
Sigma 80-400mm F4.5-5.6 ($1000-1100) with vibration reducing system or faster
Sigma 100-300mm F4 ($800). Both of the lens are getting whole lot better opinions from the owners than the 135-400mm.
If you don't like Nikkor 18-200mm lens, then I would recommend Tamron 28-75mm lens over Nikkor 18-70mm (which you probably meant with 17-80mm). For the range you could get either 70-300mm or 55-200mm, which are both about $200 - although both of those are really just temporary solutions. You really can't get a good "long" zoom for cheap.