Originally posted by Toad:
Impress me with your command of the language? Just wondering.
I'd love to, but you prabably wouldn't understand, considering that its unlikely that you read Polish. English is my second language, and as such i feel under no obligation to write like Shakespeare.
The reason there is opposition to the "voucher system" is that it is a challenge to the status quo. It's as simple as that.
The education of our youth, good, bad or indifferent, is no longer the issue. The side that opposes vouchers is afraid to experiment in search of a better solution because it might mean the dreaded "change".
From Webster:
Entry Word: conservative
Function: adjective
Text: 1 tending to resist or oppose change
Quite amazing that its liberals that oppose it, isn't it ?
Our education system needs serious improvement. To unilaterally rule out experiments that might radically alter the way we do it pretty much guarantees that the present system will continue ad infinitum with its typically poor results.
Actually, i would argue that an education system that works already exists in other places of the world. Problem is that in US its been "improved" upon so much, that it lost its initial purpose.
Point in case - i came here when i was 17, from a country under communist "mind control", poor and "without freedom". Even though i was a C student in Poland, when it came to picking out classes in US for my Senior year in HS, it turned out that college level math classes covered things i've done 3 years earlier.
Then, geography !!! It isn't anywhere on corriciulum for elementary school or high school ! No wonder that in my college "Intro to Geography" ( oh! Humanity ! ) class - someone thought portugal was in South America.
As it currently stands, level of education of High School graduate in United States is on average comarable of education of a middleschool graduate in europe. This is made up by high emphasis on specialization in college, but still doesn't produce a well rounded person - just a highly specialized simpleton.
Why not take a few cities and fund a good trial of the idea? Are we afraid it might work?
First of all, "good ideas" in this case is nothing more then an assumption. As far as i'm conserned - this is another step, yet farther away from the goal that american educational system long lost.
If we are going to improve the schools, we are going to have to change something; that's just a simple, obvious fact.
Oh yes, we definately do !!! But, putting taxpayers money into private school owner's hands isn't the answer.
We need to change the attitude in the society, where everyone's ultimate goal is to be an NFL player. Where people educated as stereotyped as "geeks" and "uncool". Today, 24 hour catroon networks play film after the film where heros don't win with their smarts but with their "super human" powers or "gigant" lasers.
Schools provide NO incentives to learn. Anyone who chooses not to bother learning can attend summer school and make up. You can float though school without one ounch of effort and no punishment is waiting for you.
Is this a fault of the educational system ? It's not. It's a fault of all the changes implemented over last 30 years to accomodate for those who can't keep the page.
Standard is set by lazy and unwilling and everyone in school suffers. College classes provided are fine - but what motivation does the "average" student have to get to those ? To be "uncool" and radiculed by his peers ?
Answer ? Let's go to basics - the schooling that worked for great many centuries.
Education is not supposed to be fun. Child given a choice would rather go outside and play. So let's stay pretending that school should be enjoyable ...
Corriculum should be one and the same for everyone. No general or college classes. One corriculum and a demanded one at that.
Those who fail ANY ONE of the classes in the
semester - have to repeat whole year ( aka - all the same classes they already attened ). Thust me - this provides a great motivation to study
No more "how to cook" classes in High School - while subjects like Geography or Biology are skipped or skimmed over. There is a clearly defined list of classical subject that young mind should learn. Any monkey can cook given one week's instruction.
And most of all... hold the parents responsible for the behaviour of the child, especially in school.
It is unacceptable for a child to cuss or disresepct the teacher. Such a distruptive child should be expelled from school to the "special" schools with discipline close to that of the military.
At the same time, we can address other issues. Teacher pay, teacher competency, higher pay for higher competency
, curriculum issues (hey, let's teach reading and writing and arithmetic for a change instead of "i'm ok, you're ok"), parental involvement, school discipline and the rest. We can experiment in all these areas.
It will be hard to give teachers a meaningful raise if we're sending all the cash to private school owners.
As far as i'm conserned, teachers starting salary where i live ( Connecticut ) should stand at 45K/year. Right now, good luck getting 25K. And people wonder why they get poor teachers... anyone with any education will go for a job in industry for 60K+.
Standards for teachers should be much higher, but also their compensation should be appropriety raised. In them lays a responsibility for a future of this nation, for it's greatness or continued demise. Why do we choose to insult those people with their wages ?
The one thing we shouldn't do, IMHO, is rule out experimenting to make things better.
Actually, let's STEP BACK to what worked before. It just might have a healthy effect on the rest of the society.
Right now schools are nothing more then social clubs and breeding grounds.
Quite pathetic really. Moving them to fancier buildings won't help.
It's a mentality that has to change.
<rant mode off>
------------------
Bartlomiej Rajewski
aka. Wing Commander
fd-ski Northolt Wing
1st Polish Fighter Wing303 (Polish) Squadron
"Kosciuszko" RAF
308 (Polish) Squadron
"City of Cracow" RAF
315 (Polish) Squadron
"City of Deblin" RAF
Turning 109s and 190s into scrap metal since 1998Northolt Wing Headquarters