Originally posted by Winks
If I'm right donut map took something like 2 years
A MA style map can be built in less than 12 hours. Which usually adds up to a few weeks considering not many (if any) map makers have the patience to sit down 12 hours straight working on a terrain. The problem with MA maps is you basically build it however you want. And what you like is not what everyone else may like. People whine about every map in rotation.
Whereas maps for the AvA and SEA are built to be historically accurate and playable. It takes a lot more time, effort and know-how to build these types of maps.
Everyone whining about the maps discourages some people from building a map for the MA. Why dedicate time and effort to something that will just be criticized and complained about?
Why not try a new approach, instead of whining, try motivating some map makers?
If I recall, there was a contest promoted by players to see who could have the most successful tour in a P40B and there was a prize for the winner? Why not do the same for a map. Maybe get some people into a contest, entering fee is $5. The $5 could be sent to HTC and build up a money pool. Give a 2-3 month deadline. Whomever builds the best map recieves the money (or it can go to paying for a few months subscription).
Win-Win situation, community gets a few more maps in rotation, motivation for some people to put effort into building a decent map.