Well, I knew you guys would come around to a realistic way of thinking...
Arty is a good thing...
Medium Arty wouldn't need AP to kill a Tank, even a Tiger...
At Kursk, in 1943, The Russians used 152's as direct fire AT guns... With standard HE rounds... HESH wasn't developed until later....
They split the Tigers open like soda pop cans.... Photo's are available!!
Remember that;
Arty, even SP's require, a surveyed controll point, for indirect fire..
There was no GPS, or PADS, or SRP/PDS, in WW2...
It takes longer than 15secs to deploy an Arty battery...
Arty would be deployed in Valleys, not on hilltops...
Their high angle fire, would reach OVER the hill....
In WW2, the germans viewed US L5/7's as the harbingers of death...
They would bring almost instant Arty fire from all directions...
US pattern Arty would be the best... Most effective by far...
105, 155long tom, and the KING of destruction, 8inch towed....
OG