Yeah the plane match-ups are silly
The G-6 entered service in 2-43, the Yak-9u in 8-44 - stupid match-up. G-6 verses the 9T is much more 'believable'
The 2 known combats of the Ta-152 were against the Tempest and Yak-9Us over Berlin. They match the Ta-152 against the Spit 14 - not quite at the stupid level but silly nonetheless...
Ta-152 verses Tempest
Spit 14 verses Fw 190D-9
Spit 16 verses the Bf 109G-14
P-51D verses the Bf 109K-4
P-47D-11 verses the Fw 190A-8 (5 is ok)
I don't care about Pacific planes so whatever...
The first rumble was fun when AH still had a dedicated LW only pilots and squads. The second rumble sucked arse so much so that the LW CO, Hristo, even didn't bother to show-up. 90% of the 'axis' side was filled with guys who didn't know a G-6 from a G-10.
All the best but next time get some one who knows a little about WW2 to do the plane match-ups. These are just as important in building interest as it is pitting Axis verse Allied pilots. There are very few of the the old protagonists to carry the rumble on its own.
You can always tell if a rumble is worth it by the amount of 'fun hate' on the forums beforehand. Seems to me this rumble has been awfully quiet. Even the WB / AH rumble generated more heat.