Flying around in these past few weeks of imbalance, I never noticed public griping, when I was on the understaffed side, about imbalance.
But yes, I can understand how imbalance could be a problem. People who have compiled the numbers these past weeks have posted on this board... something like:
Orange:
Bish- 60
Knits- 75
Rooks- 120
Blue:
Bish- 125
Knits-100
Rooks- 60
Seems pretty imbalanced, no? What if you could add them together somehow, maybe some sort of super mega arena....
Bish- 185
Knits- 175
Rooks- 180
..........nah, that would never work.
Perhaps sample size is the problem here. Not anyone's "naughtiness" of not personally taking the initiative to switch sides to whichever side, that day, has the numbers. With any small sample size you are going to see fluctuation, sometimes severe. There is the possibility that having two Late War (Main) arenas just splits up the numbers enough so that usually there will be a side imbalance.
Look, I'm not advocating going back to the old MA. I'm just simply acknowledging that all of these problems (ENY inflation, the need for a new capture system) arose from a chain of events starting with that switch.
Sometimes the best way to start a problem is to go back and fix it from the roots, rather than go forward with another new innovation that has the potential of ultimately, down the chain, starting new problems itself.
This is bad for squads. I am not in a squad, and personally I have no problem changing sides, but I can understand that people rightfully want to fly with their buddies, and making it a hassle for them to do so is going to make this game more of a chore than enjoyment. As long as every third new person who registers is assigned bishop, the next knight, and the next rook, etc, I don't see how this numbers imbalance won't correct itself in the long run if everyone is allowed to fly in the same arena.