What's really benefits Africa... Western donation/charities or Chinese Loans?

[1K3]

My take on this...

Western charities and donations help Africans escape hunger for 1 day, but Chinese loans (billions worth) improves the situations of the Africans in the long run.  The Chinese are also there building infrastructures, even in the most remote regions of Africa.

[Xargos]

Beware of Greeks bearing gifts.

[Sandman]

Let's just look at the abysmal failure of the welfare system in this country. We have dynasties of state dependents.

Charity only goes so far.

[lasersailor184]

Originally posted by Sandman
Let's just look at the abysmal failure of the welfare system in this country. We have dynasties of state dependents.

Charity only goes so far.

Agreed.  I have little sympathy for most of africa.  When they stop screwing themselves over, then I'll have more sympathy.

[Xargos]

I feel sorry for most of those people.  I lived in Africa for 4 years when I was younger.  Africa is proof of what happens when there is no middle class.

[Pei]

Originally posted by 1K3
Chinese loans (billions worth) improves the situations of the Africans in the long run.  The Chinese are also there building infrastructures, even in the most remote regions of Africa.

Assuming the money doesn't go into various peoples' swiss bank accounts.

[lukster]

Originally posted by 1K3
My take on this...

Western charities and donations help Africans escape hunger for 1 day, but Chinese loans (billions worth) improves the situations of the Africans in the long run.  The Chinese are also there building infrastructures, even in the most remote regions of Africa.

The "west" has been doing far more than just feeding Africans for "1 day" for many decades.

Communism or fundamentalist Islam? Not sure which will be the great evil in Africa but I am sure that neither will promote individual liberty.

[lazs2]

charity and hand outs don't promote individual liberty either.

lazs

[lukster]

Originally posted by lazs2
charity and hand outs don't promote individual liberty either.

lazs

Hand outs certainly don't but charity comes in many forms. A missionary who provides medical treatment or helps a village to build a crop irrigation facility is certainly being charitable while helping a people to become self sufficient.

[lasersailor184]

Originally posted by lukster
Hand outs certainly don't but charity comes in many forms. A missionary who provides medical treatment or helps a village to build a crop irrigation facility is certainly being charitable while helping a people to become self sufficient.

What about when that village kicks the farmer out and "nationalizes" his land?

[Maverick]

Loans are great but only work when there is an ability to repay them and the interest without bankrupting the debtor. What has the majority of Africa , or at least the section being considered, got to use to repay any loans?

Handouts are great for the moment. They don't necessarily promote self reliance.

[Sandman]

Originally posted by lasersailor184
What about when that village kicks the farmer out and "nationalizes" his land?

The village then gets the pleasure of watching their agricultural efficiency plummet, followed by the pleasure of starving.

[Maverick]

Don't they have that now??? Why should anyone want to spoil their fun?

[1K3]

Originally posted by lukster
The "west" has been doing far more than just feeding Africans for "1 day" for many decades.

And so far it's been a failure.  Western charities are there in Africa just to give food/used clothes and in return you have to believe and submit to The Lord Jesus Christ (TM).  There's just no economic development there other than to keep them alive.  Chinese investments/loans on the other hand are transforming even the 6th world countries to respective 3rd or 2nd status,

[lasersailor184]

Originally posted by Sandman
The village then gets the pleasure of watching their agricultural efficiency plummet, followed by the pleasure of starving.

You're not half bad sometimes.