yes youve made it alot clearer, sorry for clogging up your old thread with useless suggestions then, should of picked up on it earlier as i too use the x52.
when i plugged it in i flew with it no problems straight off the bat, i havent got round to programming all the throttle axis yet, as flying with auto-trim is enough to think about for me at this point..
anyway onto a response to the questions, now by not being able to trim, do you mean, youve assigned all the axis to the functions, and the mapping screen shows movement in the axis (the numbers change) but in-flight the same axis has no effect on the trimmings of the plane?
as for the extreme controls it does sound like a deadband/dampning issue, just out of interest, when u pull full back, for example, how much movement are you getting? i dont know if this was mentioned in the other thread, but it could be the stall limiter
then again you sound like you know a bit about the game, so i doubt youd have overlooked that point.
if you havent already done so, read through the link provided by fugitive in the other post (
this one )
and if you have done so and are still having problems, report back, it may be worth suggesting some time in the training arena with a trainer, thats how i fine tuned my x52, but having someone instructing you as your looking at it makes it alot simpler, and may help