Originally posted by Karnak
Didn't look like the Empire of Japan was in its death throes there. Not at all. Looked like the Spitfire Mk VIIIs were hopelessly outclassed.
Well, those Spitfire pilots were certainly outclassed.
Given equal pilots, the Spitfire VIII is the better fighter. Faster, better acceleration, better climb, virtually identical turn radius and the Spitfire is more stable at the limit.
I've dueled a few of the Ki-84 advocates/experts with a Spitfire VIII. The Spitfire was the better fighter. Not much better, but enough. Largely because the Ki-84 is a handful when slow with full flaps, having a tendency to snap-spin when increasing AoA quickly. While the Spitfire is far more stable, allowing more violent AoA changes without getting as squirrelly.
That said, a well flown Ki-84 is a very able and dangerous enemy, as Batfink clearly demonstrated.
My regards,
Widewing