Originally posted by aerosaber
...
I just found it strange that this practice is so dissed. Not defending myself, no need, just conversation.
I get the HO as much as anyone else. I usually lose, but dont start sending nastygrams to the guy who killed me.
The reason that they are dissed is because:
a) In real life, no one would deliberately gamble their lives on a 50/50 dice roll every time they engaged an enemy aicrcraft -and-
b) Generally, in real life pilots had some training. You didn't just show up one day and have an endless supply of factory fresh aircraft to zoom around in.
It's one of the things that detracts from the enjoyment of the moderately skilled pilot, because he's trying to play a different game than "Whee!!!! Let's get a kill at any cost!".
Personally, I no longer have very much trouble with them. At one time though in a different sim I did - I was much less skilled, and flying what was modeled as an anemic gunned aircraft that bled E like a stuck pig meant that an HO you avoided could kill you faster than one you took.
Bruv119 has the right of it - there's a big difference between an merge where the guy is planning to HO you, and one where he isn't. And often times, the guys who are avoiding the HO do so by too large of an amount, and give up angles in the process - or even worse position themselves for an off-center deflection shot.
It sounds contradictory, but what Bruv119 says is basically true. If the guy's going HO you avoid it and go for the angles, if the guy isn't you watch for a deflection shot if he's cut the margin too fine, and if he swings too far wide he gives up angles as you lead turn behind him.
Believe me, I've been there with the frustration. All I can say is that eventually, you don't have much trouble with it any more.
I just wish I could see better a lot of the time. Any more, when I end up HO 9 out of 10 times it's because I thought I was coming at his 6 and I'm headed straight into his teeth. I may maneuver if I realize soon enough, but if there isn't time, I usually fire in the hopes of spoiling his shot.