My ATI 9700 Pro died several months ago. I replaced it a few weeks ago with a 7800 GS AGP, a well reviewed card. It arrived DOA. After pondering trying something else high end, I noticed the local computer place had an MSI 6200 for sale for $69. Its working almost as well as the ATI did, I get some severe stutters by trees (thus why I cringed when i saw the news of MORE new trees soon).
I think the best money for me is to upgrade to a new system. Im still waiting for the Core Duos to drop a bit more.