I have long held the same general opinion expressed by Zazen in this post.
Zazen!
When it comes to a "smart" flying strategy, or a "risk it all" strategy, I don't think it can or should be seperated quite to the extent expressed by some.
There is a lot of middle ground to play with. Personally, I want to defeat my opponents- that is my goal. So I fly somewhat "smart". However- I don't want to beat them because all the variable's are in my favor, whether it be #'s, altitude, speed, etc. So I try to set up engagements that are somewhat even, and challenging. I don't mind being disadvantaged, and will often set myself up that way purposely. Baiting the trap was a good way to describe it. I hunt IRL as a major pasttime. But I do it with a flintlock rifle and/or a redtail hawk. Why do it if you need all the advantages of modern technology?
At the same time, I'm not going to fly "stupid", just to give someone else the satisfaction of beating me. No matter what the situation, I'm going to try to come out of it the victor. What is the fun of beating someone if they aren't also trying to win. I don't feel I need to land all the time, and my stats will show I die the majority of my hops. But winning IS my goal, so landing will come hand in hand with that. Anybody can go find a furball and die in it. It takes more brain-power to come out alive. Unless of course you just hang out and wait for cherries.
Most chnl 200 whining is baseless anyway. I took off from a field a few days ago, with a fully fueled corsair. A higher, lighter, better turning plane(KI-84) was above me, chasing a friendly. The friendly died, at which point the enemy plane dropped onto my six. The fight was running East/West, so I "ran" North. I was purposely dragging this con out to a "private" fight, out of line of the furball. Also realize that this was the only enemy in sight, with about eight friendlies nearby, not to mention ack, etc.
So, I'm on the deck, with a KI-84 on my six D1000 back. It would have been pointless for me to try to beat him immediately, so why try? Even if I had tried, and lived a bit, he would have been ganged. Where's the fun there? One friendly asked if I needed help, and I told him TY, but no I was fine. So I dragged him out of icon range of the field, where we could both have a higher quality fight. He wouldn't get ganged, and I'd have some speed to manuever. He came on chnl 200 and cried because I was running away, and wouldn't fight without an advantage. He also mentioned how I would always run to friends and wouldn't fight alone. As soon as we were out of icon range of my countrymen, I let him overshoot, and smoked his engine. He promptly inverted his plane and bailed. Who has the advantage in fight like this? Our social structure is making it difficult for Darwin's theory to come to fruition nowadays I think. My personal opinion is that folks like this would have been trampled by a mammoth in the old days.
Personally, I would much prefer to fight someone else who is using their brain and putting up a challenging fight. If they are getting beat, and have the opportunity to extend and re-engage, then they should. They don't need to head to the next county, but extending out 2-3K is reasonable. Beating some of the more skilled pilots in this game is where the most satisfaction comes from. But not when they are helpless. What is the point?
MtnMan