In the spirit of Zazens thread

[Dichotomy]

Why did I die

Instead of chest thumping how about we start posting when we didn't do so well?

How about getting Murdr, Widewing, Ghosth, Skyrock, Hubs, Krusty, Biggles, Schatzi, Schutt, and a host of others to look at our films when we got our rears handed to us?

It's called constructive criticism and I'm more than happy to receive it.  

That said.  Keep it CONSTRUCTIVE.  None of us need some smart mouthed know it all saying 'you suck'.

What would a good stick do in that situation to turn the tables?

GV'rs, knife fighters, bnzrs, post your films here when you got capped and lets let the old school guys pick us apart and give us new ideas on how to handle different situations.

I got hits on Waffle tonight (I admit I HO'd him in frustration) but being TAUGHT how to survive and land kills by others no matter your method of playing can go a long way in keeping this game fresh and healthy.

Gentlemen and ladies I am your guinea pig.  

Have at me.

[JB88]

Originally posted by Dichotomy



I got hits on Waffle tonight...

oh.  like that's hard.

[5PointOh]

Not sure what you did wrong, cause I do the same things as you with the same results.  I also fly the 51D. So I am curious to see what the vets say.

[Dichotomy]

Originally posted by JB88
oh.  like that's hard.

BE QUIET!!! I ORDER YOU TO BE QUIET!!!!

5oh as am I .. just having fun with JB

[5PointOh]

I always feel like easy prey  Would like to understand where I go wrong.  I'll take some films this week and send them to the cutting block.

<>

[-CodyC]

They'd probably say don't fly a p51 j/k

It is a good idea, wouldn't mind having Dolfo(killnu) or other 109 guys fight me or look at a film and see what im doing wrong.  I highly doubt, however, that they have the time for that.  I know i sure don't.

[hubsonfire]

Ewww, ponies. I'm definitely not qualified to comment. I'm in the running for worst runstang pilot this year. Again.

[Drano]

IMO you should have been more agressive while you were 2 v 1(really 3 v 1 for a while) and the other Pony was purely defensive. As it was you "played with your food" so to speak while he took the fight in the direction of friendlies. Maybe its just your gunnery is about as bad as mine is! Looked like you hit him at least once if not twice good enough to cause wing damage or a pilot wound--but he flew right on.

 You both got overly focused on killing the pony even while there were other NME in the area. I was watching with your views on. I see you didn't notice the Corsair until he was about 1K out and about to shoot at you.  No chatter between you and your wingie. One of you should have been watching while the other was attacking. Roles should alternate. If the situation was about to change --the entry of the F4U--somebody should have made that known so that threat could have been evaded. You can't kill if you don't avoid being killed and in this case that was completly avoidable. SA went to hell at a critical moment of the fight. Can't be too cute and have blinders on in indian country.

The fight really turned when niether of you noticed the F4U in time although the other Pony was gaining a shot at that time as well.

Hope this helped. Off to bed.

Drano

[BaldEagl]

Here's a few things I noticed.

Not sure if it's the film viewer or if your views are really set up that way but if they are I can't imagine how you can see out the back.  If it's not the film viewer you have to adjust and save your views, especially back.

When the P-51 turns back to you the first time you wait too long to turn.  In fact there is both that and another time (when you smoke him) where you seem fixated on a HO shot rather than maintaining pursuit.

When you are in pursuit you should keep him in sight more often and for longer periods while always pulling to bring him into your forward view.  Of course this assumes you tried to turn for angles on the merge rather than go for the HO.

After the first turn or two, when he drops to the treetops he scissors and slows down and you essentially overshoot above him.  This forces you to turn back to him setting up both the HO shot that smokes him and the shot by the other plane that takes you down.  Had he been in your forward view and you reacted correctly you could have dropped throttle, remained on his six and gotten the kill plus you would have seen the other plane coming in from in front of you in this particular instance.  The best way to kill a scissors is to get slower than the scissoring plane, maintain a relatively straighter line and take the snap-shots from a slight distance as he crosses your nose.

Mostly I'd say keep him in your forward view, which in matched planes should have been easy.  You don't have a gun solution any other way.

[humble]

I'll make a few observations....

These are from memory after 1 viewing up till your engine quits....

1) on his initial reverse your flying right at him, not reacting to him early...this enables alot of angular gain on his part.

2) as he goes vertical your viewing your horizon line not him. Watch clips from any of the vets....we're "locked" on to the target.

3) You zoom to guns as soon as you get a shot....I could care less about HO's or other whinning but a shot taken at the expense of angles is a bad thing (if he doesnt die) {this is where you "lost" the fight}....

4) as a result of your shot selection you allow him to create a rolling scissors in which you carry to much speed and get forced out front....

5)...your enginer died:D

It's not easy to go from decent to good, and going from good to better then good is even tougher {since i'm still about thast speed I dont know how you get to really really good but I'm trying}

Viewing this as a former trainer my biggest area of concentration would be on teaching you to take the initiative early on. You need to counter his opener quickly and create seperation....

"Straight at em" {from master and commander} might work with sailing ships....but trading broadsides isnt ACM....also you were not only reactive but "in plane" all to often.

[Souless]

Want Honesty?
                            You shoulf have had him on your second merge IMO, poor shooting cost you

[Guppy35]

Originally posted by Souless
Want Honesty?
                            You shoulf have had him on your second merge IMO, poor shooting cost you

I trust this means you are back in the skies now?

Ya gotta quit leaving all the time

[JB88]

Originally posted by Dichotomy
BE QUIET!!! I ORDER YOU TO BE QUIET!!!!

that's pretty funny stuff... for a dead guy.

[Dichotomy]

good stuff gents..


okay who's next to post a film and be critiqued?

I'll put another one up tonight if nobody else feels like taking the initiative.

[Murdr]

I'll just pick two issues.  

"This is a very important point about overshoots; you have to recognize one when it happens."  You had like 2-3 seconds after comming abeam to do something to avoid going where he could pull guns, and just kept going straight into his potential flight path.

You're trigger finger is consistantly late.  The difference between when I want to pull the trigger and shots are fired are like .5-1 second.  That 2nd merge in particular, you waited until he came into view from behind the canopy frame which was too late.  You need to lead the target more, and often that means guessing where the target will be, and shooting at that empty spot of air whether you can see the target or not.  I shoot down a lot of planes that I have no view of when I pull the trigger.