Originally posted by Nilsen
Are you saing that the hit on the hood magazine and the hit on bismarcks rudder were well aimed intentional hits and not lucky diablo?
Nilsen, for the most part, yes I do, especially the hit on the Hood. Remember the Bismarck straddled the Hood very early in the encounter. Battleships are DESIGNED to be tough, even battlecruisers though not to the extent BB's are. A hit was inevitable. A hit to the magazine, either 15" or smaller shell storage, was a forgone conclusion, Jutland showed this. The RN just never took the time to bring Hood back in for it's armor improvements that was planned for it. It was no more a lucky hit than what the PoW did to the Bismarck. Fire Control had advanced mightly between the world wars. A hit was a given, it was up to the naval designers to cope with this inevitability. Unfortunately for the Hood, that was 20 years too late.
A BB's broadside was designed to be like a stupendously large shotgun blast; at least you hope one shell hits from the broadside but the more the better. If you want to talk about luck, you might want to look up the Warspite's record of the longest hit from a BB to a target at sea. Remember that was an aimed shot as well, very little luck played a part in it.
Also remember the rear gunner of the swordfish that dropped the torpedo was the one that the rear gunner actually told the pilot when to release by hanging over the side and visually aiming. Was it lucky? To a great extent yes it was. Was it aimed and calculated? Yes, to some extent it was as well. Who's to say they weren't aiming for the rudders, or that the rear gunner was thinking the same thing. I think some luck and some skill played a part in this.
But the bottom line is this: One 14" shell crippled the Bismarck in terms of mission completion. The lack of a concentrated AA suit finished her. Not one, zero, nil, none, nada of the swordfish were shot down during all of the attacks, at least none that I know of. She was a grand ship, a mighty ship, but not without her glaring achilles heel(s) much like the Hood.