Originally posted by storch
a few weeks back my daughter was test driving a new car she wanted to purchase. they were pulled over by an unmarked car plus about seven other marked units pulled out of the vehicle tossed to the pavement which was scaldingly hot cuffed and dragged to the swale. this occurred during a period in time when two deputies were shot in the line of duty and they were hunting white cars with stolen tags.
[/B]
Storch, I agree to a point, especially given the circumstances, but....
An (assumably) young(er) lady with a car salesman does not add up to a threat worth "drag out of car, face plant in dirt, ask questions later" behavior. Although the officers may have been acting within the scope of their duties, did you not wonder why they didn't do an ID, or possibly a Terry Search, or give them a chance to explain that they were on a test drive.
I live in Philly, and believe you me, I see some of the crap that cops put up with. Most are square fellows until you disrespect them or make their job harder un-necessarily. I have all the respect in the world for the police that are protecting my neighborhood, but if that happened to my daughter, I can't say that I wouldn't be having a "chat" with my attorney, until I(we) found some divergence from proper procedure. I mean come on, daddy's little girl, (again, unsure of age), but, sometimes there is such a thing as too extreme.
I do not single you out, its just that your post leapt out at me. I have seen some very atrocious things done to some very innocent people under the "within the scope of my duty" umbrella. Sometimes right outside my front window. I'll use the anology of do you REALLY need the 10 lb sledge hammer when a framing hammer will suffice? Sure the sledge will work, but was it necessary.
I'm certainly not trolling here, just had to get that off my chest. I'm a firm proponent for the rights granted to me and others by the 4th amendment, and beilieve that anyone who is an officer should have the wherewithall to tulips the threat level of a situation, and ask questions first if no immediate threat is appearent.
Storch