All right, so the issue isn't the password recovery, it's the fact that I have multiple emails and can't figure out which one the password is being sent to. 
I just reformatted my comp so all my cookies were deleted. Pw's included. I guess I never went back and changed my pw for AH. If I could get some help with this, my ingame name is tattered, and my most used email is 
dreamt4reality@yahoo.com, that would be great. 
Maybe you could send the email that is connected with tattered to 
dreamt4reality@yahoo.com so I know where my pw is being sent that would help a lot. 
Thanks again.