Originally posted by trax1 
I just went to the website(http://www.firesafecigarettes.org/) of the group that pushed this law to see if I could find any info or a report on smoking fire related deaths in New York that show they have actually gone down because New York was the first state to pass this law back in 2004, and I couldn't find any.  Now I would assume that if there had actually been a significant reduction in smoking fire related deaths it would be posted on there site to back up their claims.  I sent an email to the contact email address on the site asking if they had any reports on this statistic, I'll let you know if they respond with the info. 
 couldn't find any stats for fires caused by smoking but did find this.
http://www.dos.state.ny.us/fire/firedata.htmfrom the section under; Annual statistical report based on fire, accident, and burn injury reports from paid and volunteer departments.
 year              total fires                civilian injuries                 civilian deaths
 2003              89,965                     631                               126
 2004              91,404                     625                               125
 2005              97,014                     574                               106
 2006              97,014                     580                               110
total fires in 05 and 06 are the same, I double checked the pages to make sure.
overall I'd say the NY State FSC law has a minimal impact on the total stats. as you can see, total fires actually went up.
[joke]I bet next on their agenda is "fire safe matches" " it burns 10mm below the matchhead then puts itself out by the exploding water capsule then you're all wet. " [/joke]