It looks like you need to have the first one at least removed from the game. It's molting does not match this reference.
There is more than one reference than the EagleCals sheet. I've seen that decal scan, and it doesn't seem to be very clear. I took it into consideration, and compared to the other references, went with them instead.
EDIT: Regarding the photo, it looks like the mottling is light. There's none on the nose beneath the demarcation line, and there's a nice chunk of it by the badge area, but looking beneath the canopy and as far as the photo shows, it's very light mottling (light as in low density, not necessarily color choice)