I'll never understand why it's rated so high (all of a sudden in my mind since I remember it being like 35 last time I noticed),
You are confusing it with the Hurricane I, which has an ENY of 40. Hurricane II never had an Eny >30 as far as I know.
And don't underestimate the IIC. If it had only average armament, I would share your opinion. But the Hispanos change evrything and set it apart from all the other TnB planes in the set.Thanks to them, it's even very capable vs BnZ attacks. You can quite easily dodge an attack, then use it's incredible maneuverabilty to bring the guns to bear the moment your enemy passes you. And not many rounds are needed to Also the Hurri is sturdier than a Spit and very stable in a dive. Of course, the puny speed is the main reason the Hurri II has no ENY 5
While, in my opinion, one could argue about the ENY 15 rating of a 190D, it's much more a one-trick pony. You need much more discipline to fight in it succesfully. A Hurri can't run away for sure, but a 190 that loses it's E advantage is in some serious trouble too.