Saitek Cyborg stick. Have had mine for about a year and although I have to put a little soap(lubricant, wax etc) where the spring meets the spring cup to get it smooth, it feels as good as new. I don't use any fancy HAT switches or the throttle even, I stick to good old numpad(for views) and bind engine throttle to 100% power to one button and 0% power to another. I wouldn't recommend that as it has it's disadvantages, but I've gotten used to it. Now if you can afford it, I've heard good things about the x52 but if you want cheap can't beat $20 bucks.