I've got a Saitek AV8R. I think it's a great stick. In fact it's the perfect replacement if you were used to a MS Sidewinder.
I really don't need a seperate throttle and all those buttons and stuff on the X52 (8 plus the hat with the ability to dual mode all of them is plenty for me) and for $40 if it breaks a year from now I'll just get another one.