The rules:
It can't be cheap.
It can't be something useful.
It can't be something usable by me.
She won't give me any ideas and is offended that I might consider asking.
Well, in Femspeak that means jewelry ... so you're absolutely buttered there. Not knowing what your wife may like.. below are some alternatives.
1) How about an exotic vacation? A cruise? Maybe tell her in xmas but the trip can take place in 09. A weekend retreat to Niagara falls or vegas or a cruise.. up to her.
2) Spa treatment. Never understood this but women seem to love to pay dearly for someone to fondle them, splat mud on their face, pin cucumber parts on their eyelids, steam cook them and all that stuff. I mean, I could do that for free

. Anyways, I think they just like to make us pay for it. Evil XX gene carriers I tell you.

3) Rent a flashy expensive convertible or bike and go out for a whole days drive.. have a romantic picnic somewhere?
4) Hire a male stripper and pop him out of a huge gift box under the tree. If she likes it YOU can be the one in the box next year.. if she doesn't then I bet you she will not nag you about the present ever again. She'll tell you what she wants or risk another cake-man. Win win situation my friend.
