I only read the first couple pages...
If I was flying for the RAF in WW2 and they assigned me a Spit XVI, I would gladly fly it. My life would be on the line, and I would want my plane to as good as possible. I would want every advantage over my opponent. I would not want the fight to be fair.
In this game, though, where the object is to have fun and where dying doesn't matter, I would hate to have to fly the Spit XVI all the time. It's not challenging, I'm not interested in it (relative to other planes), and I would look like a dweeb.
If the original poster is trying to draw some sort of parallel between the two situations, I think they're grasping at straws. AH2 =/ WW2, and anyone insinuating that we should, for some reason, act like this is an actual war needs take a deep breath and step away from the keyboard.