Jameson is awesome, although I also love equally Glennfiddich and Glenlivett (sp?)
I bought a bottle for my old man, who really loves scotch, but we're both struggling with it... Laphroaig..... must be a very acquired taste..... INTENSE peat smoke flavor, a glassful with a few cubes of ice and you feel like you're drinking a rainy glass of campfire ashes mixed with scotch.
Laphroaig is one of my favorites but it needs to be sipped neat and (IMO) tastes best at room temps - maybe put a couple of drops of water at the most to bring out the flavour a bit(seriously) but definitely no ice or mix. Too much water, or ice, will produce pretty much the taste you described. Drink it neat and you get the smokey, peaty flavour with hints of taste like the ocean smells on a clean beach with an onshore breeze.
My regular drink is 12yr old Aberlour. Very smooth and tastey but a whole bunch of dollars cheaper (up here) than Laphroaig.
which reminds me....
I'm thirsty.
Cheers,
asw