I gave up and started feeding both, Now my birds get seed, and my squirrels get Peanuts. I just buy a big 50lb bag from the feed store and it only runs about $20.00 a month. I put them right outside of my (home ) office window and they have a blast. Its gotten so that i recognize and have named most that come to the peanut feeder. THe good thing is that they also have plenty of acorns around naturally, so if im late putting out the peanuts, they go scavenging for the acorns They dont bother with the birdseed anymore.