who would win?

[Wildcat1]

ok, how about MiG-29 v. super hornet?

thats an even fight if ive ever seen one

[Imowface]

the super hornet can do the cobra manuver as well

not saying it cant, just disproving the extreme ACM statement 

[Heater]

Lot of "Unknowns" but in a straight up knife fight the Su-27 would have the upper hand.

[Shuffler]

I'm calling it equal if the Su27 was not thrown together like so many of the russian aircraft have been through the years.

[dedalos]

went to an airshow in Jacksonville, Florida a couple weeks ago and was wondering....

in a no-holds-bar dogfight, with pilots of equal skill, who would win, the F/A-18 or the Su-27?

honest, un-biased answers please.

The one caring the better missile and radar. 

[bcadoo]

The one caring the better missile and radar. 

I think it would depend on the skill and training of the pilot.