you are once again, quite wrong...you're one of those 60minutes/48hours is 100% true people aren't you? that's where all this "alternative" parenting started going into full swing out of the hippie communities...because of those 2 shows and the way they stretched the truth about children being physically abused.
i've always been amazed at how people without children managed to convince a large part of the parental population that alternative parenting was the only way to raise children...yet the statistics show that the first generation of those raised under those concepts have more social problems than their parents who were raised with corporal punishment did at the same age...higher crime, higher suicide, higher drug use...look it up, if the studies weren't buried.
when i was a kid...the most dangerous thing on the playground was a pocket knife, and no one pulled one on you for fear of corporal punishment at school and at home...now 12 year olds raised by the "time out" generations are carrying guns and shooting adults...dealing drugs...bullying people live and in person as well as on the web...
now, there is a limit to how corporal punishment should be administered...one rule that few adults know or even understand is "never hit a child when you're angry"...my generation failed to comprehend that rule and now the "here's a cookie 2 minute time out stupid nanny" generation is making it difficult for reasonably sane parents to actually raise their children to be responsible adults.
Balderdash.
My father grew up during "the good old days", and corporal punishment didn't stop the kids in his school from becoming vegetables from fighting with baseball bats, shooting each other's heads off with shotguns, or doing a myriad of hard drugs. It's the environment, not punishment which creates 'bad company'.
However, punishment can influence it heavily. If you beat your kids, they will learn that it is alright to beat those weaker than they are. You don't know who that is going to be- the old lady who gets in his/her way, the annoying brat down the street, etc. The problem is that the teenage brain recognizes bad choices, but only recognizes the good consequences (hint: it's why 18-19 year old boys love to drive fast and hump anything that moves). You are essentially creating a Terminator, and unleashing it on the world at large.
-Penguin