The effect the 12 hour rule has had is destabilization of ENY in a way. I suppose I could take the time and run the #s...I have a job so that's not going to happen, so here is what I have noticed. I log on on Saturday morning, ENY has Bish as low #s. I jump to bish. Why...because I look for the fight, and the reward..ergo perkies. Then by noon, the Bish are now the high number. The mob is stabbing and jabbing, I would prefer to defend against the mob... well, no choice there, I have made my bed and must lay in it.
Folks who ought not be in this discussion:
1. Squads who rotate on a monthly or whatever basis.
2. Squads who only fly one country.
3. X-File believers who think that some malevolent force is giving up the ghost to all of their plans (spies).
Lets face it, a PM works as good as a squad vox. If anyone wants to "spy" they can and will, the point is moot. Having a hour rule associated to counter this notion is absurd.
Back to my original point, if we persist with 12 hour rule, then, do away with ENY. The entire point of ENY was to balance the fight and to serve as an incentive to change sides to even the numbers. Throughout the weekend hours, the numbers fluctuate enough, that 12 hours is not reactive enough. 2-4 is probably a bit better. Hell, I like the one hour thing best. If you are not one of the three people listed above, all you are looking for is a fair and fun fight, regardless of the chess piece. You should not be limited in your seeking of the fight by some artificial rule of no substance.