Wishlist

[DMVIAGRA]

GV's
M18 Hellcat
M10 Wolverine
M26 Pershing (Limited use during WWII, qualified due to service)
Sd. Kfz. 184 Elefant
Sd.Kfz. 164 Nashorn
SdKfz 173 Jagdpanther
SdKfz 167 Stug IV
Cromwell
Churchill
Marder III
Hetzer

Aircarft
F8F Bearcat
P35 Guardsman
P61 Black Widow
P63 King Cobra
A-26 Invader
He 162 (For completion of jet platform)
P-40N
P-40F
He-111
Blackburn Roc

I know this is a rather crappy list, I need opinions though. I know for sure we need the P-63, He-111, and an allied tank to compete with the Tigers and Panther's.

I really don't urge the addition of German tank destroyers though, Nashorn would be nice though!

[skorpion]

you forgot the StuG III Ausf G. and the Yak-3.

other than that i'd say theres not much to add.

[B-17]

Blackburn Roc? Any particular reason?

I'm not saying no, just wondering why.

And I might say that an earlier B-17 model and/or the Ju-52 should be added, if only for the purpose of providing a more acurate flight model for Snapshots.

[Tyrannis]

GV's
M18 Hellcat
M10 Wolverine
M26 Pershing (Limited use during WWII, qualified due to service)
Sd. Kfz. 184 Elefant
Sd.Kfz. 164 Nashorn
SdKfz 173 Jagdpanther
SdKfz 167 Stug IV
Cromwell
Churchill
Marder III
Hetzer

Aircarft
F8F Bearcat
P35 Guardsman
P61 Black Widow
P63 King Cobra
A-26 Invader
He 162 (For completion of jet platform)
P-40N
P-40F
He-111
Blackburn Roc

I know this is a rather crappy list, I need opinions though. I know for sure we need the P-63, He-111, and an allied tank to compete with the Tigers and Panther's.

I really don't urge the addition of German tank destroyers though, Nashorn would be nice though!

I dont believe the Bearcat saw any service in WW2, or atleast not enough to make it eligible for inclusion.

The p63 is an ongoing controversy tho, There was a huge thread about it (60+pages i think) of people trying to prove/disprove that it ever saw combat.

Some say it saw action in Manchuria against the Japs, Some say it didn't see action at all.

The black widow is a split decision as well, some people want it, some people dont. The people that dont say that because there is no night time, there is no need for it.

[titanic3]

It's a wishlist, post whatever you want.  

Here's mine:

He-115
He-111
Do-17/217
Ju-87G
Ki-100
H8K
Ju-188
Ju-88G
He-177
He-219
ME-262-A2 (R4M Air-to Air Rockets)
Me-410
Ki-43
Mustang Mk I
Ju-52

[Tyrannis]

ME-262-A2 (R4M Air-to Air Rockets)

Jesus Christ no.

[titanic3]

Jesus Christ no.

It's unguided, it's on hit explosion, not time (distance?) fused like the Wrg21s.

All it has over firing the normal HE rockets is a flatter trajectory. Which, if you happened to ever try, is almost impossible to hit a moving target. All it would be good for is against large (and I mean LARGE) formations of buffs. Or, as I imagine in AH, rocket vulching. But then again, if the vulch light is lit, don't bother upping.

[Butcher]

It's a wishlist, post whatever you want.  

Here's mine:

He-115
He-111
Do-17/217
Ju-87G
Ki-100
H8K
Ju-188
Ju-88G
He-177
He-219
ME-262-A2 (R4M Air-to Air Rockets)
Me-410
Ki-43
Mustang Mk I
Ju-52

I agree with this list, Me-262-A2 I can do without, better then adding 1946 aircraft or <insert any tank here just to beat a tiger>

Although a 1946 list would be interesting.

[Scotty55OEFVet]

Aircraft-

Yak-3
Bristol Beaufighter
HE-111
Do-17

Ground Vehicles-
AEC Armoured Car MKIII
Tank, Cruiser, Mk.VIII, Cromwell
M26 Pershing
SU-100 tank destroyer
IS-3 (Iosif Stalin 3)
SdKfz 162 Jagdpanzer IV (Rather see this than the Nashorn because almost 2000 built compared to a little under 500 of the Nashorn)

[Rino]

Blackburn Roc? Any particular reason?

I'm not saying no, just wondering why.

And I might say that an earlier B-17 model and/or the Ju-52 should be added, if only for the purpose of providing a more acurate flight model for Snapshots.

     To give this some aerial competition...Okinawa 1945 btw 

[Karnak]

I think the OP needs to crack open a wider variety of books on WWII aircraft.

ROC?  Seriously?

[mbailey]

     To give this some aerial competition...Okinawa 1945 btw 
(Image removed from quote.)

Just had to do it didnt you...

[jimson]

Aircarft
F8F Bearcat
P35 Guardsman
P61 Black Widow
P63 King Cobra
A-26 Invader
He 162 (For completion of jet platform)
P-40N
P-40F
He-111
Blackburn Roc

A little Allied heavy I'd say.

I don't even want to see another Allied plane until at least 2 Japanese fighters, 1 Russian bomber and 1 German bomber have been added, in fact not even then, we could make the next ten aircraft Axis.

[Karnak]

A little Allied heavy I'd say.

I don't even want to see another Allied plane until at least 2 Japanese fighters, 1 Russian bomber and 1 German bomber have been added, in fact not even then, we could make the next ten aircraft Axis.

It isn't Allied heavy, it is American heavy.  The only non-American Allied airplane on the list is the pathetic ROC.  He basically advocates a bunch of American stuff, and then, possibly to make it look less biased, puts in the worst British aircraft he can find.


I do think he has a good chance at getting those P-40s he wants as Pyro did strongly hint at a stronger P-40 lineup soonish.

[Charge]

My wishlist:

I want these crappy lists to go away.

I want wishlists to reside in Wishlist forum.

I want some sense in these crappy lists that should be on the Wishlist forum.


Ok, thats not much and I do not want any opinions on these. Just my humble 2 cents and 10 years of playing AH.

-C+

PS. For quite obvious reasons maybe next time when we have a planeset vote lets give the people a weighed vote based on how long they have played this game. Eg. divide the years by two to get the total weight of the vote (1y would still count 1). Does that sound unfair? What I think is unfair is that people who have spent a long long time in this game and possess an insight of what would be good for the game have just the same vote as those who would stumble in yesterday with no understanding at all for what is actually needed and what is not.