I never said there was Miracle at Midway. Did you say there was a Shattered Sword at Midway? Prange covers a lot of the blunders as well. No one book is going to make you an expert on the battle I don't care who wrote it. Prior to Shattered Sword anyone who read the numerous books on the subject or even wargamed the battle could come up with the same assestments as Shattered Sword. Again SS is an excellent book but just because you read it doesn't mean others can't have an opinion on the battle.