So you dispute what exactly in your argument?
I never really disputed anything in my argument.
You see, I took semp's word for it when he claimed to not be a member of the Allied forum. This confused the heck out of me because I couldn't figure out how he could see my posting history in that forum.
It has since been revealed that semp was, in fact, a member of the Allied forum. Therefore my two theories about how he could have got that info are invalid.
There is not some crazy bug that allows non-members to view the forum and it is not likely that anyone from inside the forum would be passing info to an outsider. At least not in this particular case.
However, semp did say that information regarding scenario battle plans is discussed freely and that there is no way to stop it, so I guess in a round about way the forums are still compromised.