Ah, the entitlement generation attempting to make AH no refuge from such mentality. 'I enjoy this game so much that I feel someone owes me.' There's not an airline in business that does't wish the guy that invented the frequent flyer program was never born.
As some that is very framilar with loyalty programs, your statement is further from the truth than usual. The programs are designed to offer loyal customers a little something more for continual use of a companies product, in turn it entices a customer to continue to be loyal.
Example: I am a member of the Intercontinental Hotel Group (formally Priorty Club). I have reached Platnium Elite status for the last 6 years, and have close to 500,000 points. It take 10,000 to 20,000 points per night to stay at one of IHG's hotel, but on average you only accumulate 5,000-7,500 per 5 night stay (and that's with the Elite 50% bonus). There are other products including gift cards to TVs and Laptop. On average a 1 night stay at a IHG hotel will be close to 120.00, even on the low end if I used all 500,000 points for room stays (500,000pts/10,000=50 stays X 120 per night) IHG only spent 6,000.00 retail dollars to keep me happy. Pretty good deal for the hotel. Figuring you only 1500 points per night, IHG 34,000.00USD on the low end. (Before you make Platnium status the points earning is smaller, maybe 500 points per night.
As for the original post, I'm not sure the loyal guy needs perks but I do like giving the new subscriber 50-100 perks in each category. Might help with new player retention.