Forcing split arenas now would be a death knell for the game. There are not enough players most of the time now to get the arena going. You have to have a certain number of players for the arena to start to be a decent playground.
The way I see it, there isn't a forced split of the arenas, just like how it is currently.
Forcing players to choose between PvE or PvP, or a staged mission arena, or the sandbox will cut numbers even more per arena.
How is providing choices for a player forcing them to choose? Players will still have the option of flying in the main arena in its current format but will have other arenas if they wish to engage in PvE missions or PvP matches, with such objectives like Capture the Flag (or base in this case), team death match, staged PvP missions, etc.
I don't see why those other types of play couldn't be incorporated into the main arena. It's just coading after all. You don't HAVE to join a staged mission, but defending against one might add to the fun. Any PvE or PvP could just be a payment choice. Limited play to what ever the payment scales are. $15 full blown account.
Because the move towards gaming habits is quick action, something the PvE and PvP arenas bring to the table and gives the player more playing options.
More options payment wise as well as game play wise will only help the game, but splitting it over a number of arenas will kill it.
Adding different payment options isn't going to bring in the crowds if there is nothing to provide the "hook" to keep them here, giving them options in addition to changes to the game play and with the new graphics will provide that "hook" to hopefully compel the new player to stick around.
People have asked why the media blitz on Canadian TV during some show about aces/dogfighting didn't pan out. My guess the reason that media campaign failed was that there wasn't anything to compel the potential customer to check out the game, let alone stick around if they did. There needs to be a change to the game, not a variation of the same old thing.
ack-ack