For the record I went to the DA with Skyyr on Saturday and I lost 1-19. I called him a BnZ, E-state-roping-one trick Pony so he challenged me to DA, which I was happy to accept, and I thank him for staying and fighting 20 rounds.
Firstly we proved I can't beat him in a duel [well 95% of the time I can't beat him in a duel]. As in the MA, in the DA Skyyr is the king of the maximizing alt-E-retension Immelmenn [or at least 8% better than I am] that makes the second merge a slow motion stall fight with him pulling up to maybe 400yrds above me hanging on his prop and me trying to line him up and missing shot ofter shot before I stall out. Then he chases me down and I die. This scenario played out about 16 times in various planes [all avoiding our favorite rides]
We discussed during the fights whether this dueling scenario, employing the same first turn that maximizes alt and E-state, disproves the one-trick-pony theory. Skyyr's point was "why would I do something less effective." My point was I think this proves my point, and If I could shoot I will have killed him a bunch of times and forced him into varied tactics that might have given the opportunity to deploy a more varied set of maneuvers and scenarios. Alas I couldn't force him out of that scenario.
There were a couple of sorties where he just unzipped his fly and I saddle him up quickly and still couldn't hit him. Then after being down 1-12 I really just start making all kinds of mistakes. But does my horrific gunnery prove anything about the original ACM discussion?
I don't know because I lost, and Skyyr won so I have to shut up until the rematch.
<S> Skyyr. Thanks for the fights.